yet there is reason to think, that in these times of corruption, for the most part, they held
circumcision and the passover; and we do not find their attending on these ordinances under
such circumstances, any more expressly charged on them as a sin, than their coming without
piety of heart. The ten tribes continued constantly in idolatry for about 250 years, and there
is a ground to suppose, that in the mean time they ordinarily kept up circumcision and the
passover. For though they worshipped God by images, yet they maintained most of the ce-
remonial observances of the law of Moses, called the manner of the God of the land, which
their priests taught the Samaritans who were settled in their stead, 2 Kings xvii. 26, 27..
Nevertheless we do not find Elijah, Elisha, or other prophets, reproving them for attending
these ordinances without the required moral qualifications. Indeed there are some things
in the writings of the prophets, which may be interpreted as a reproof of this; but no more
as a reproof of this, than of attending God’s ordinances without a gracious sincerity and
true piety of heart and life.
How many seasons were there, wherein the people in general fell into and lived in idol-
atry, that scandal of scandals, in the times of the judges, and of the kings both in Judah and
Israel! But still amidst all this wickedness, they continued to attend the sacrament of circum-
cision. We have every whit as much evidence of it, as that they attended the passover without
a profession of godliness. We have no account of their ever leaving it off at such seasons,
nor any hint of its being renewed (as a thing which had ceased) when they came to reform.
Though we have so full an account of the particulars of Josiah’s reformation, after the long
and scandalous reign of Manasseh, there is no hint of any reviving of circumcision, or return-
ing to it after a cessation. And where have we an account of the people being once reproved
for attending this holy sacrament while thus involved in scandalous sin, in all the Old Test-
ament? And where is this once charged on them as a sin, any more than in the case of un-
converted persons attending the sacrament of the passover?(
Answ. 2. Whatever was the case with respect to the qualifications for the sacraments of
the Old-Testament dispensation, I humbly conceive it is nothing to the purpose in the
present argument, nor needful to determine us with respect to the qualifications for the
sacraments of the christian dispensation, which is a matter of such plain fact in the New
Testament. Far am I from thinking the Old Testament to be like an old almanack out of use;
nay, I think it is evident from the New Testament, that some things which had their first
institution under the Old Testament, are continued under the New; for instance, the accept-
ance of the infant-seed of believers as children of the covenant with their parents; and
probably some things belonging to the order and discipline of christian churches, had their
first beginning in the Jewish synagogue. But yet all allow that the Old-Testament dispensation
is out of date, with its ordinances; and I think, in a matter pertaining to the constitution and
order of the New-Testament church—a matter of fact, wherein the New Testament itself is
express, full, and abundant—to have recourse to the Mosaic dispensation for rules or pre-
1835
OBJ. III. Jews partook of the Passover.