328 JEROME.
Vice is next-door neighbour to virtue. It is hard to rest content with God alone for
judge. 1 6. L. I was reserving that passage until
last, and you have anticipated my question
about it. Almost all our party, or rather not
mine any more, use it as a sort of controversial
battering ram : as such I am exceedingly
glad to see it broken to pieces and pulverized.
But will you be so good as to fully explain to
me, not in the character of an opponent but of
a disciple, why it is that the Church receives those who come from the Arians ? The
truth is I am unable to answer you a word,
but I do not yet give a hearty assent to what
you say.
17. O. When Constantius was on the throne
and Eusebius and Hypatius were Consuls,
there was composed, under the pretext of
unity and faith,1 an unfaithful creed, as it is now acknowledged to have been. For at
that time, nothing seemed so characteristic of
piety, nothing so befitting a servant of God,
as to follow after unity, and to shun separa- tion from communion with the rest of the
world. And all the more because the cur-
rent profession of faith no longer exhibited
on the face of it anything profane. " We
believe," said they, " in one true God, the Father Almighty. This we also confess :
We believe in the only begotten Son of God,
who, before all worlds, and before all their
origins,2 was born of God. The only-begotten Son, moreover, we believe to be born alone of
the Father alone, God of God, like to his Father
who begot Him, according to the Scriptures ;
whose birth no one knows, but the Father
alone who begot Him." Do we find any such
words inserted here as 3 " There was a time,
when he was not ? " Or, " The Son of God is a creature though not made of things which
exist." No. This is surely the perfection of faith to say we believe Him to be God of God.
Moreover, they called Him the only begotten,
" born alone of the Father." What is the' meaning of born? Surely, not made. His
birth removed all suspicion of His being a
creature. They added further, " Who came
down from heaven, was conceived of the Holy
Ghost, born of the Virgin Mary, crucified by
Pontius Pilate, rose again the third day from
the dead, ascended into heaven, sitteth at the
right hand of the Father, who will come to
judge the quick and the dead." There was a ring of piety in the words, and no one thought
1 For an account of the "Dated Creed " here referred to, and of the Councils of Seteucia and Ariminum, A. D. 359. see
Bright's History of the Church, A. D. 313-451, fourth edition, pp. 03-100.
2 Principium, the equivalent of the Greek 'Apx>i, which means beginning, or principle, or power.
3 These two propositions constituted the essence of the teach- ing of Arius.
that poison was mingled with the honey of
such a proclamation.
1 8. As regards the term ' Usia, it was not rejected without a show of reason for so
doing. 2 " Because it is not found in the
Scriptures," they said, " and its novelty is a stumbling-block to many, we have thought it
best to dispense with it." The bishops were not anxious about the name, so long as that
which it implied was secured. Lastly, at the
very time when rumour was rife that there
had been some insincerity in the statement of
the faith, Valens, bishop of Mursa, who had
drawn it up, in the presence of Taurus the
pretorian prefect who attended the Synod by
imperial command, declared that he was not
an Arian, and that he utterly abhorred their
blasphemies. However, the thing had been,
done in secret, and it had not extinguished
the general feeling. So on another day, when
crowds of bishops and laymen came together
in the Church at Ariminum, Muzonius, bishop
of the province of Byzacena, to whom by
reason of seniority the first rank was assigned
by all, spoke as follows : " One of our number has been authorized to read to you, reverend
fathers, what reports are being spread and
have reached us, so that the evil opinions
which ought to grate upon our ears and be
banished from our hearts may be condemned
with one voice by us all." The whole body of bishops replied, Agreed. And so when
Claudius, bishop of the province of Picenum,
at the request of all present, began to read
the blasphemies attributed to Valens, Valens
denied they were his and cried aloud, " If any- one denies Christ our Lord, the Son of God,
begotten of the Father before the worlds, let
him be anathema." There was a general
chorus of approval, " Let him be anathema." 3 " If anyone denies that the Son is like the Father according to the Scriptures, let him
be anathema." All replied, " Let him be
anathema." "If anyone does not say that
1 Usia (ovcri'a) is defined by Cyril of Alexandria as that which has existence in itself, independent of everything else to con- stitute it. A discussion of both it and its companion term
hypostasis may be found in Newman's Arians, Appendix p. 432. Around ouo-i'a, or some compound of the word, the great Arian controversy always raged. In asserting that the son was homo- ousios with the Father, i.e., consubstantial or co-essential, the Church affirmed the Godhead of the Son. But ihe formula
experienced varying fortunes. It was disowned as savouring of
heterodoxy by the Council of Antioch (264-269) which was held to decide upon the views of Paulus : was imposed at Nicaea
(325) : considered inexpedient by the great body of the epis- copate in the next generation : was most cautiously put forward
by Athanasius himself (see Stanley's Hist, of Eastern Church, 1883, P- 24°* : does not occur in the catecheses of S. Cyril of
Jerusalem (347) : was momentarily abandoned by 400 bishops at
Ariminum who were " tricked and worried " into the act. '• They
had not," says Newman. " yet got it deeply fixed in their minds as a sort of first principle, that to abandon the formula was to
betray the faith." 2 The distinguishing principle of the doctrine of Acacius was
adherence to Scriptural phraseology. See Bright's Hist., p. 6q. 3 The teaching of Aetius and Eunomius, the Anomosans, who
were the extremists of the Arians. See Robertson's Hist, of Chris. Ch., fourth edition, pp. 236237, etc. The other tenets
anathematized are Arian or Semi-Arian.