and purify them costs infinite labor, and, after all, can be done only partially. If it is going
too far to attribute this state of alarm to the Deity himself, his members at least must have
dreaded the prospect of suffering all these evils. Then, again, if they were ignorant of what
was to happen, the substance of your god must have been so far wanting in prescience. How
many evils do you reckon in your chief good? Perhaps you will say that they had no fear,
because they foresaw, along with the suffering, their liberation and triumph. But still they
must have feared for their companions, if they knew that they were to be cut off from their
kingdom, and bound for ever in the mass of darkness.
16. Had they not the charity to feel a kindly sympathy for those who were doomed to
suffer eternal punishment, without having committed any sin? These souls that were to be
bound up with the mass, were not they too part of your god? Were they not of the same
origin, the same substance? They at least must have felt grief or fear in the prospect of their
own eternal bondage. To say that they did not know what was to happen, while the others
did, is to make one and the same substance partly acquainted with the future, and partly
ignorant. How can you call this substance the pure, and perfect, and supreme good, if there
were such evils in it, even before its mixture with the evil principle? You will have to confess
your two principles either both good or both evil. If you make two evils, you may make
either of them the worse, as you please. But if you make two goods, we shall have to inquire
which you make the better. Meanwhile there is an end to your doctrine of two principles,
one good and the other evil, which are in fact two gods, one good and the other evil. But if
hurting another is evil, they both hurt one another. Perhaps the greater evil was in the
principle that first began the attack. But if one began the injury, the other returned it; and
not by the law of compensation, an eye for an eye, which you are foolish enough to find
fault with, but with far greater severity. You must choose which you will call the worse,—the
one that began the injury, or the one that had the will and the power to do still greater injury.
The one tried to get a share in the enjoyment of light; the other effected the entire overthrow
of its opponent. If the one had got what it desired, it would certainly have done no harm
to itself. But the other, in the discomfiture of its adversary, did great mischief to part of itself;
reminding us of the well-known passionate exclamation, which is on record as having been
actually used, "Perish our friends, if that will rid us of our enemies."779 For part of your god
was sent to suffer hopeless contamination, that there might be a covering for the mass in
which the enemy is to be buried for ever alive. So much will he continue to be dreaded even
when conquered and bound, that the security, such as it is, of one part of the deity must be
purchased by the eternal misery of the other parts. Such is the harmlessness of the good
principle! Your god, it appears, is guilty of the crime with which you charge the race of
darkness—of injuring both friends and enemies. The charge is proved in the case of your
779 Quoted Cic. pro Dejor. § 9.
462
Faustus denies that Manichæans believe in two gods. Hyle no god. Augustin…