the protestant religion before the popish, in a conscientious care to do many duties, in being
willing to take a great deal of pains in religion, in being sorry for the commission of such
and such acts of wickedness, &c. But there are some duties, which, unless they are done with
a gracious sincerity, they cannot be done at all. As Mr. Stoddard observes, (Safety of Ap. p.
216.) “There are some duties which cannot be done but from a gracious respect to God.“
Thus, there is but one sort of sincerity in loving God as God, and setting our hearts on him
as our highest happiness, loving him above the world, and loving holiness above all the objects
of our lusts. He that does not these things with a gracious sincerity, never really doth them
at all. He that truly does them, is certainly a godly man; as we are abundantly assured by the
word of God. So, there is but one sort of sincere and cordial consent to the covenant of grace,
but one sort of giving all our hearts to Jesus Christ; which things Mr. W. allows to be necessary,
to come to sacraments. That to which a man’s heart is full of reigning enmity, he cannot
with any reality at all cordially consent to and comply with: but the hearts of unsanctified
men are full of reigning enmity to the covenant of grace, according to the doctrine of
Scripture, and according to the doctrine of Mr. S. and Mr. W. too, as we have seen before.
However, if there were any such thing, as being heartily willing to accept of Christ, and
a giving all our hearts to Christ, without a saving sincerity, this would not be a complying
with the terms of a covenant of salvation. For it is self-evident, that only something which
is saving, is a compliance with the terms of salvation. Now Mr. W. himself often allows (as
has been observed) that persons must comply with the terms of the covenant of grace, in
order to come to sacraments.—Yet because he also in effect denies it, I shall say something
further in confirmation of it.
1. The sacraments are covenant privileges. Mr. W. himself calls them so. (p. 5. a. b.)
Covenant privileges are covenant benefits, or benefits to which persons have a right by the
covenant. “But persons can have no right to any of the benefits of a covenant, without
compliance with its terms. For that is the very notion of the terms of a covenant, viz. Terms
of an interest in the benefits of that covenant. It is so in all covenants whatsoever; if a man
refuses to comply with its conditions, he can claim nothing by that covenant.
2. If we consider the sacraments as seals of the covenant, the same thing is evident, viz.
That a man can have no right to them without a compliance with the terms. The sacraments
are not only seals of the offer on God’s part, or ordinances God has appointed as confirma-
tions of the truth of his covenant, as Mr. W. seems to insist. (p. 74, 75.) For considered
merely as seals and confirmations of the truth of the gospel, they are (as miracles and other
evidences of the christian religion) seals equally given to Christians, Jews, Deists, moral and
vicious, and the whole world that knows of them. Whereas, it is manifest, in the nature of
the thing, sacraments are seals of the covenant to be applied to the communicant, and of
which he is the immediate subject, in a peculiar manner, as a party in covenant. Otherwise,
what need would there be of his being one of God’s covenant people, in any sense whatsoever?
1948
SECTION VIII. Of sincerity.