That it is unfinished cannot be doubted; for (a) In the
Proëmium he announces his purpose to carry it to the year a.d. 439, or the seventeenth consulate of
Theodosius; but this is not done with any of his ordinary fullness,
although his hints reach beyond, as we have seen. (b) In lauding
Pulcheria (ix. 1) he remarks, “That new heresies have not
prevailed in our time, we shall find to be due especially to her, as we
shall subsequently see.” Here is the declared purpose of
delineating the history of Nestorianism and its overthrow, but there is
no appearance of the struggle in the record itself; he altogether
passes by Nestorius, as bishop of Constantinople. (c) The record of the forty martyrs he purposely took
out of its normal order, to illustrate the excellence of Pulcheria; a
late event is anticipated, but the whole of what would have been its
normal setting is not there. (d) One would naturally expect that a book
which had thus far treated mainly of state difficulties would have the
usual balance, at least, and that ecclesiastical affairs would have
preponderated in the remaining chapters; but there is only an initial
chapter. Seventeen chapters are not his usual tale for a book; there is
an evident break; the discussion of Nestorianism is not written. Most
of all would one expect some allusion to the restoration of Chrysostom
under Proclus. (e) In ix. 16, he says, “Among other relics, those
of Zechariah, the very ancient prophet, and of Stephen, who was
ordained deacon by the Apostles, were discovered; and it seems
incumbent upon me to describe the mode, since the discovery of each was
marvelous and divine;” but he gives only the invention of
Zechariah (c. 17). The story of Stephen fails us, and would doubtless
have followed immediately. It was his purpose to narrate the
story,—this story which Theophanes and Marcellinus mention and
Lucianus wrote a book about. (f) In c. ix. 17, this is confirmed; for
he says, “I shall first speak of the relics of the
prophet”; to his second he does not come. (g) The close is
abrupt; one feels instinctively that something is amiss. Hence the
work, as we have it, is obviously not complete.