(g) Athanasius in 362. The difficulty here
is that Athanasius clearly returned after the murder of George,
which, according to Amm. Marc. XXII. xi., took place upon the receipt
at Alexandria of the news of the execution of Artemius at Antioch,
which latter event must be placed in July. Therefore Athanasius would
not have returned till August, 362. On the other hand the Hist.
Aceph. makes George arrested four days after his return to
Alexandria, and immediately upon the proclamation of the new Emperor,
Nov. 30, 361. On Dec. 24 George is murdered, on Feb. 9 the edict for
the return of the exiles is promulged, and on Feb. 21 Athanasius
returns, to take flight again ‘eight months’ later, on Oct.
24. The difficulty is so admirably sifted by Mr. Gwatkin (pp. 220, 221)
that I refer to his discussion instead of giving one here. His
conclusion is clearly right, viz., that Ammianus here, as occasionally
elsewhere, has missed the right order of events, and that George was
really murdered at the time stated in Hist. Aceph. The only
addition to be made to Mr. Gwatkin’s decisive argument is that
Ammianus is inconsistent with
himself, and in agreement with the Hist. Aceph., in dating the
arrest of George shortly after his return from court. As George
would not have been at Julian’s court, this notice implies
that the arrest took place only shortly after the death of Constantius.
Moreover, George, who even under Constantius was not over-ready to
visit his see, and who knew well enough the state of heathen feeling
against him, would not be likely to return to Alexandria after Julian
had been six months on the throne. We have then not so much to balance
Ammianus against the Hist. Aceph., as to balance one of his
statements, not otherwise confirmed, against another which is supported
by the Hist. Aceph., and by other authorities as well,
especially Epiph. Hær. 76. 1. (The Festal Index
gives no precise date here, except Oct. 24, for the flight of
Athanasius, which so far as it goes confirms the Hist. Aceph.)
Moreover, “on the side of Ammianus there is at worst an
oversight; whereas the Hist. Aceph. would need to be
re-written.” The murder of George, Dec. 24, 361, return of
Athanasius, Feb. and his flight, Oct. 24, 362, may therefore be taken
as firmly-established dates.