26. The judges said: If you allege that the shepherd exposed the kid or the lamb to the
lion, when the said lion was meditating an assault1664 on the unbegotten, the case is closed.
For seeing that the shepherd of the kids and lambs is himself proved to be in fault to them,
on what creature can he pronounce judgment, if it happens that the lamb which has been
199
given up1665 through the shepherd’s weakness has proved unable to withstand the lion, and
if the consequence is that the lamb has had to do whatever has been the lion’s pleasure? Or,
to take another instance, that would be just as if a master were to drive out of his house, or
deliver over in terror to his adversary, one of his slaves, whom he is unable afterwards to
recover by his own strength. Or supposing that by any chance it were to come about that
the slave was recovered, on what reasonable ground could the master inflict the torture on
him, if it should turn out that the man yielded obedience to all that the enemy laid upon
him, seeing that it was the master himself1666 who gave him up to the enemy, just as the kid
was given up to the lion? You affirm, too, that the shepherd understood the whole case be-
forehand. Surely, then, the lamb, when under the lash, and interrogated by the shepherd as
to the reason why it had submitted to the lion in these matters, would make some such answer
as this: “Thou didst thyself deliver me over to the lion, and thou didst offer no resistance to
him, although thou didst know and foresee what would be my lot, when it was necessary
for me to yield myself to his commandments.” And, not to dilate on this at greater length,
we may say that by such an illustration neither is God exhibited as a perfect shepherd, nor
is the lion shown to have tasted alien meats; and consequently, under the instruction of the
truth itself, it has been made clear that we ought to give the palm to the reasonings adduced
by Archelaus. Archelaus said: Considering that, on all the points which we have hitherto
discussed, the thoughtfulness of the judges has assigned us the amplest scope, it will be well
for us to pass over other subjects in silence, and reserve them for another period. For just
as, if1667 a person once crushes the head of a serpent, he will not need to lop off any of the
other members of its body; so, if we once dispose1668 of this question of the duality, as we
have endeavoured to do to the best of our ability, other matters which have been maintained
in connection with it may be held to be exploded along with it. Nevertheless I shall yet address
myself, at least in a few sentences, to the assertor of these opinions himself, who is now in
our presence; so that it may be thoroughly understood by all who he is, and whence he
1664 Migne reads irrueret. Routh gives irruerat, had made an assault.
1665 The text gives si causa traditus, etc. Routh suggests sive causa. Traditus, etc.; so that the sense would be,
For on what creature can the shepherd of the kids and lambs pronounce judgment, seeing that he is himself
proved to be in fault to them, or to be the cause of their position? For the lamb, having been given up, etc.
1666 Reading eum ipse for eum ipsum.
1667 Reading si quis for the simple quis of Codex Casinensis.
1668 Reading “quæstione rejecta” for the relecta of Codex Casinensis.
Chapter XXVI.
467
Chapter XXVI.