Chapter 41.—About the Discord of Philosophic Opinion, and the Concord of the
Scriptures that are Held as Canonical by the Church.
But let us omit further examination of history, and return to the philosophers from
whom we digressed to these things. They seem to have labored in their studies for no other
end than to find out how to live in a way proper for laying hold of blessedness. Why, then,
have the disciples dissented from their masters, and the fellow-disciples from one another,
except because as men they have sought after these things by human sense and human
reasonings? Now, although there might be among them a desire of glory, so that each wished
to be thought wiser and more acute than another, and in no way addicted to the judgment
of others, but the inventor of his own dogma and opinion, yet I may grant that there were
some, or even very many of them, whose love of truth severed them from their teachers or
fellow-disciples, that they might strive for what they thought was the truth, whether it was
so or not. But what can human misery do, or how or where can it reach forth, so as to attain
blessedness, if divine authority does not lead it? Finally, let our authors, among whom the
canon of the sacred books is fixed and bounded, be far from disagreeing in any respect. It
is not without good reason, then, that not merely a few people prating in the schools and
gymnasia in captious disputations, but so many and great people, both learned and unlearned,
in countries and cities, have believed that God spoke to them or by them, i.e. the canonical
writers, when they wrote these books. There ought, indeed, to be but few of them, lest on
account of their multitude what ought to be religiously esteemed should grow cheap; and
yet not so few that their agreement should not be wonderful. For among the multitude of
philosophers, who in their works have left behind them the monuments of their dogmas,
no one will easily find any who agree in all their opinions. But to show this is too long a
task for this work.
But what author of any sect is so approved in this demon-worshipping city, that the rest
who have differed from or opposed him in opinion have been disapproved? The Epicureans
asserted that human affairs were not under the providence of the gods; and the Stoics,
385
holding the opposite opinion, agreed that they were ruled and defended by favora ble and
tutelary gods. Yet were not both sects famous among the Athenians? I wonder, then, why
Anaxagoras was accused of a crime for saying that the sun was a burning stone, and denying
that it was a god at all; while in the same city Epicurus flourished gloriously and lived securely,
although he not only did not believe that the sun or any star was a god, but contended that
neither Jupiter nor any of the gods dwelt in the world at all, so that the prayers and supplic-
ations of men might reach them! Were not both Aristippus and Antisthenes there, two
noble philosophers and both Socratic? yet they placed the chief end of life within bounds
so diverse and contradictory, that the first made the delight of the body the chief good, while
the other asserted that man was made happy mainly by the virtue of the mind. The one also
said that the wise man should flee from the republic; the other, that he should administer
About the Discord of Philosophic Opinion, and the Concord of the Scriptures that are Held as Canonical by the Church.
872
About the Discord of Philosophic Opinion, and the Concord of the Scriptures…