the judgment of truth. You maintain that the fruit suffers when it is pulled from the tree,
when it is cut and scraped, and cooked, and eaten. So you are wrong in eating anything
that can not be swallowed raw and unhurt, so that the wound inflicted might not be from
you, but from your follower in pulling them. You declare that you could not give release
to so great a quantity of life, if you were to eat only things which could be swallowed without
cooking or mastication. But if this release compensates for all the pains you inflict, why is
it unlawful for you to pull the fruit? Fruit may be eaten raw, as some of your sect make a
point of eating raw vegetables of all kinds. But before it can be eaten at all, it must be pulled
or fall off, or be taken in some way from the ground or from the tree. You might well be
pardoned for pulling it, since nothing can be done without that, but not for torturing the
members of your God to the extent you do in dressing your food. One of your silly notions
is that the tree weeps when the fruit is pulled. Doubtless the life in the tree knows all things,
and perceives who it is that comes to it. If the elect were to come and pull the fruit, would
not the tree rejoice to escape the misery of having its fruit plucked by others, and to gain
felicity by enduring a little momentary pain? And yet, while you multiply the pains and
troubles of the fruit after it is plucked, you will not pluck it. Explain that, if you can! Fasting
itself is a mistake in your case. There should be no intermission in the task of purging away
the dross of the excrements from the spiritual gold, and of releasing the divine members
from confinement. The most merciful man among you is he who keeps himself always in
good health, takes raw food, and eats a great deal. But you are cruel when you eat, in making
your food undergo so much suffering; and you are cruel when you fast, in desisting from
the work of liberating the divine members.351
5. With all this, you venture to denounce the sacrifices of the Old Testament, and to
call them idolatry, and to attribute to us the same impious notion. To answer for ourselves
in the first place, while we consider it no longer a duty to offer sacrifices, we recognize sac-
rifices as part of the mysteries of Revelation, by which the things prophesied were foreshad-
owed. For they were our examples, and in many and various ways they all pointed to the
one sacrifice which we now commemorate. Now that this sacrifice has been revealed, and
has been offered in due time, sacrifice is no longer binding as an act of worship, while it re-
tains its symbolical authority. For these things "were written for our learning, upon whom
the end of the world is come."352 What you object to in sacrifice is the slaughter of animals,
though the whole animal creation is intended conditionally in some way for the use of man.
You are merciful to beasts, believing them to contain the souls of human beings, while you
refuse a piece of bread to a hungry beggar. The Lord Jesus, on the other hand, was cruel to
351 [In bringing to notice the absurdities of the Manichæan moral system, Augustin may seem to be trifling,
but he is in reality striking at the root of the heresy.—A.H.N.]
352 1 Cor. x. 11.
287
Faustus avows his disbelief in the Old Testament and his disregard of its…