His third section, p. 76, consists of three parts:— First,
“That some” (wherein it is apparent that I am chiefly, if not only,
intended) “do found a religion upon a pretended acquaintance with Christ’s
person, without and besides the gospel;” whereunto he opposeth his running
title of “No acquaintance with Christ but by revelation.” Secondly, A
supposition of a scheme of religion drawn from the knowledge of Christ’s
person; whereunto he opposeth another, which he judgeth better. Thirdly,
An essay to draw up the whole plot and design of Christianity, with the
method of the recovery of sinners unto God. In the first of these, I
suppose that I am, if not solely, yet principally, intended; especially
considering what he affirms, pp. 98, 99, namely, that “I plainly confess
our religion is wholly owing unto acquaintance with the person of Christ,
and could never have been clearly and savingly learned from the gospel, had
we not first grown acquainted with his person.” Now, herein there is an
especial instance of that truth and honesty wherewith my writings are
entertained by this sort of men. It is true, I have asserted that it is
necessary for Christians to know Jesus Christ, — to be acquainted with his
person that is (as I have fully and largely declared it in the discourse
excepted against), the glory of his divine nature, the purity of his human,
the infinite condescension of his person in the assumption of our nature,
his love and grace, etc., as is at large there declared: and
now I add, that he by whom this is denied is no Christian. Secondly, I
have taught, that by this knowledge of the person of Christ, or an
understanding of the great mystery of godliness, God manifested in the
flesh, which we ought to pray for and labour after, we come more fully and
clearly to understand sundry other important mysteries of heavenly truth;
which without the knowledge of Christ we cannot attain unto. And how
impertinent this man’s exceptions are against this assertion, we have seen
already. But, thirdly, that this knowledge of Christ, or acquaintance with
him, is to be attained before we come to know the gospel, or by any other
means than the gospel, or is any other but the declaration that is made
thereof in and by the gospel, was never thought, spoken, or written by me,
and is here falsely supposed by this author, as elsewhere falsely charged
on me. And I again challenge him to produce any one letter or tittle out
of any of my writings to give countenance unto this frontless calumny. And
therefore, although I do not like his expression, p. 77, “Whoever would
understand the religion of our Saviour, must learn it from his doctrine,
and not from his person,” for many reasons I could give; yet I believe no
less than he, that the efficacy of Christ’s mediation depending on God’s
appointment can be known only by revelation, and that no man can draw any
one conclusion from the person of Christ which the gospel hath not
expressly taught; because we can know no more of its excellency, worth, and
works, than what is there revealed: whereby he may see how miserably
ill-will, malice, or ignorance hath betrayed him into the futilous pains of
writing this section upon a contrary supposition falsely imputed unto me.
And as for his drawing schemes of religion, I must tell him, and let him
disprove it if he be able, I own no religion, no article of faith, but what
is taught expressly in the Scripture, mostly confirmed by the ancient
general councils of the primitive church, and the writings of the most
learned fathers, against all sorts of heretics, especially the Gnostics,
Photinians, and Pelagians, consonant to the articles of the church of
England, and the doctrine of all the reformed churches of Europe. And if
in the exposition of any place of Scripture I dissent from any that, for
the substance of it, own the religion I do, I do it not without cogent
reasons from the Scripture itself; and where, in any opinions which learned
men have (and, it may be, always had) different apprehensions about, which
hath not been thought to prejudice the unity of faith amongst them, I hope
I do endeavour to manage that dissent with that modesty and sobriety which
becometh me. And as for the schemes, plots, or designs of religion or
Christianity, given us by this author and owned by him (it being taken
pretendedly from the person of Christ, when it is hoped that he may have a
better to give us from the gospel, seeing he hath told us we
must learn our religion from his doctrine and not from his person); besides
that it is liable unto innumerable exceptions in particular, which may
easily be given in against it by such as have nothing else to do, whereas
it makes no mention of the effectual grace of Christ and the gospel for the
conversion and sanctification of sinners, and the necessity thereof unto
all acts of holy obedience, — it is merely Pelagianism, and stands
anathematised by sundry councils of the ancient church. I shall not,
therefore, concern myself farther in any passages of this section, most of
them wherein it reflects on others standing in competition for truth and
ingenuity with the foundation and design of the whole; only I shall say,
that the passage of pp. 88, 89, — “This made the divine goodness so
restlessly zealous and concerned for the recovery of mankind; various ways
he attempted in former ages, but with little success, as I observed before;
but at last God sent his Son, our Lord Jesus Christ, into the world,” —
without a very cautious explanation and charitable construction, is false,
scandalous, and blasphemous. For allow this author, who contends so
severely for propriety of expressions, against allusions and metaphors, to
say that the divine goodness was “restlessly zealous and concerned” (for,
indeed, such is our weakness, that, whether we will or no, we must
sometimes learn and teach divine things in such words as are suited to
convey an apprehension of them unto our minds, though, in their application
unto the divine nature, they are incapable of being understood in the
propriety of their signification, though this be as untowardly expressed as
any thing I have of late met withal); yet what colour can be put upon, what
excuse can be made for, this doctrine, that “God in former ages, by various
ways, attempted the recovery of mankind, but with little success,” I know
not. Various attempts in God for any end without success, do not lead the
mind into right notions of his infinite wisdom and omnipotence; and that
God, by any way, at any time, attempted the recovery of mankind distinctly
and separately from the sending of his Son, is lewdly false.