III. Mr. W. to make my scheme appear the more ridiculous, more than once represents
it as my opinion, that in order to persons being admitted into the church, there must be a
judgment of their being regenerate, founded on such a degree of evidence, as that it shall
not be liable to be mistaken more than once in ten times. Thus, (p. 63. c.) “Mr. Edwards
himself supposes, in his own scheme, when he has made a positive judgment that every one
singly whom he admits into the church is regenerate; yet when taken collectively, it is
probable one in ten will be an hypocrite.” (So, p. 71. b.) “If any thing be intended to the
purpose for which this argument is brought, I conceive, it must mean, that there must be
such a positive judgment of the real holiness of persons, as is not mistaken more than once
in ten times.”—Now, I desire the reader to observe what is the whole ground, on which he
makes such a representation. In explaining my opinion, in the beginning of my Inquiry, (p.
6.) I desired it might be observed, that I did not suppose we ought to expect any such degree
of certainty of the godliness of those who are admitted into the church, as that when the
whole number admitted are taken collectively, or considered in the gross, we should have
any reason to suppose every one to be truly godly; though we might have charity for each
one that was admitted, taken singly, and by himself. And to show, that such a thing was
possible, I endeavoured to illustrate it by a comparison, or supposed case of probability of
ten to one, in the example of certain stones, with such probable marks of a diamond, as by
experience had been found not to fail more than once in ten times. In which case, if a partic-
ular stone were found with those marks, there would be a probability of ten to one, with re-
spect to that stone, singly taken, that it was genuine: but if ten such were taken together,
there would not be the same probability that every one of them was so; but in this case, it
is as likely as not, that some one in the ten is spurious. Now it is so apparent, that this par-
ticular degree of probability of ten to one is mentioned only as a supposed case, for illustration,
and because, in a particular example, some number or other must be mentioned, that it
would have been an affront to the sense of my readers to have added any caution, that he
should not understand me otherwise. However, Mr. W. has laid hold of this, as a good
handle by which he might exhibit my scheme to the world in a ridiculous light; as though
I had declared it my real opinion, that there must be the probability of just ten to one, of
true godliness, in order to persons’ admission into the church. He might with as much ap-
pearance of sense and justice, have asserted concerning all the supposed cases in books of
arithmetic, that the authors intend these cases should be understood as real facts, and that
they have written their books, with all the sums and numbers in them, as books of history;
and if any cases mentioned there only as examples of the several rules, are unlikely to be
true accounts of fact, therefore have charged the authors with writing a false and absurd
history.
IV. Another thing, yet further from what is honourable in Mr. W. is this; That, whereas
I said as above, that there ought to be a prevailing opinion concerning those that are admitted,
1907
SECTION II. Degrees of evidence.