Chapter 84.—183. Petilianus said: "But if authority had been given by some law for
persons to be compelled to what is good, you yourselves, unhappy men, ought to have been
compelled by us to embrace the purest faith. But far be it, far be it from our conscience to
compel any one to embrace our faith."
184. Augustin answered: No one is indeed to be compelled to embrace the faith against
his will; but by the severity, or one might rather say, by the mercy of God, it is common for
treachery to be chastised with the scourge of tribulation. Is it the case, because the best
morals are chosen by freedom of will, that therefore the worst morals are not punished by
integrity of law? But yet discipline to punish an evil manner of living is out of the question,
except where principles of good living which had been learned have come to be despised.
If any laws, therefore, have been enacted against you, you are not thereby forced to do well,
but are only prevented from doing ill.2193 For no one can do well unless he has deliberately
chosen, and unless he has loved what is in free will; but the fear of punishment, even if it
does not share in the pleasures of a good conscience, at any rate keeps the evil desire from
escaping beyond the bounds of thought. Who are they, however, that have enacted adverse
laws by which your audacity could be repressed? Are they not those of whom the apostle
says that "they bear not the sword in vain; for they are the ministers of God, revengers to
execute wrath upon them that do evil?"2194 The whole question therefore is, whether you
are not doing ill, who are charged by the whole world with the sacrilege of so great a schism.
And yet, neglecting the discussion of this question, you talk on irrelevant matters; and while
you live as robbers, you boast that you die as martyrs.2195 And, through fear either of the
laws themselves, or of the odium which you might incur, or else because you are unequal
to the task of resisting, I do not say so many men, but so many Catholic nations, you even
glory in your gentleness, that you do not compel any to join your party. According to your
way of talking, the hawk, when he has been prevented by flight from carrying off the fowls,
might call himself a dove. For when have you ever had the power without using it? And
573
hence you show how you would do more if you only could. When Julian, envying the peace
of Christ, restored to you the churches which belonged to unity, who could tell of all the
massacres which were committed by you, when the very devils rejoiced with you at the
opening of their temples? In the war with Firmus and his party, let Mauritania Cæsariensis
itself be asked to tell us what the Moor Rogatus2196 suffered at your hands. In the time of
2193 See below, 95, 217, and c. Gaudentium, I. 25, 28 sqq.
2194 Rom. xiii. 4.
2195 Augustin speaks of the Moor Rogatus, bishop of Cartenna in ecclesiastical province of Mauritania
Cæsariensis in his ninety-third epistle, to Vincentius, c. iii. 11. We learn from the eighty-seventh epistle, to
Emeritus, sec. 10, that the followers of Rogatus called the other Donatists Firmiani, because they had been sub-
jected to much cruelty at their hands under the authority of Firmus.
2196 Cp. note 3, p. 556.
Chapter 84
1128
Chapter 84