powers. He asks why, after the better class of spirits have been invoked, the worse should
be commanded to perform the wicked desires of men; why they do not hear a man who has
just left a woman’s embrace, while they themselves make no scruple of tempting men to
incest and adultery; why their priests are commanded to abstain from animal food for fear
of being polluted by the corporeal exhalations, while they themselves are attracted by the
fumes of sacrifices and other exhalations; why the initiated are forbidden to touch a dead
188
body, while their mysteries are celebrated almost entirely by means of dead bodies; why it
is that a man addicted to any vice should utter threats, not to a demon or to the soul of a
dead man, but to the sun and moon, or some of the heavenly bodies, which he intimidates
by imaginary terrors, that he may wring from them a real boon,—for he threatens that he
will demolish the sky, and such like impossibilities,—that those gods, being alarmed, like
silly children, with imaginary and absurd threats, may do what they are ordered. Porphyry
further relates that a man, Chæremon, profoundly versed in these sacred or rather sacrilegious
mysteries, had written that the famous Egyptian mysteries of Isis and her husband Osiris
had very great influence with the gods to compel them to do what they were ordered, when
he who used the spells threatened to divulge or do away with these mysteries, and cried with
a threatening voice that he would scatter the members of Osiris if they neglected his orders.
Not without reason is Porphyry surprised that a man should utter such wild and empty
threats against the gods,—not against gods of no account, but against the heavenly gods,
and those that shine with sidereal light,—and that these threats should be effectual to con-
strain them with resistless power, and alarm them so that they fulfill his wishes. Not without
reason does he, in the character of an inquirer into the reasons of these surprising things,
give it to be understood that they are done by that race of spirits which he previously de-
scribed as if quoting other people’s opinions,—spirits who deceive not, as he said, by nature,
but by their own corruption, and who simulate gods and dead men, but not, as he said,
demons, for demons they really are. As to his idea that by means of herbs, and stones, and
animals, and certain incantations and noises, and drawings, sometimes fanciful, and some-
times copied from the motions of the heavenly bodies, men create upon earth powers capable
of bringing about various results, all that is only the mystification which these demons
practise on those who are subject to them, for the sake of furnishing themselves with merri-
ment at the expense of their dupes. Either, then, Porphyry was sincere in his doubts and
inquiries, and mentioned these things to demonstrate and put beyond question that they
were the work, not of powers which aid us in obtaining life, but of deceitful demons; or, to
take a more favorable view of the philosopher, he adopted this method with the Egyptian
who was wedded to these errors, and was proud of them, that he might not offend him by
assuming the attitude of a teacher, nor discompose his mind by the altercation of a professed
assailant, but, by assuming the character of an inquirer, and the humble attitude of one who
was anxious to learn, might turn his attention to these matters, and show how worthy they
433
Of Porphyry’s Epistle to Anebo, in Which He Asks for Information About the…