59. After so many proofs against them, at which
even the devil who is their father Or. ii. 73, n. 7. had himself
been abashed and gone back, again as from their perverse heart they
mutter forth other expedients, sometimes in whispers, sometimes with
the drone περιβομβοῦσι. De Decr. 14, n. 1; also de Fug. 2, 6. Naz.
Orat. 27, 2. c. of gnats; ‘Be it so,’ say
they; ‘interpret these places thus, and gain the victory in
reasonings and proofs; still you must say that the Son has received
being from the Father at His will and pleasure;’ for thus they
deceive many, putting forward the will and the pleasure of God. Now if
any of those who believe aright S.
Ignatius speaks of our Lord as ‘Son of God according to the will
(θέλημα) and
power of God.’ ad Smyrn. 1. S. Justin as ‘God and
Son according to His will, βουλήν.’ Tryph. 127, and ‘begotten from the Father at
His will, θελήσει.’ ibid. 61. and he says, δυνάμει καὶ
βουλῇ
αὐτοῦ. ibid. 128. S.
Clement ‘issuing from the Father’s will itself quicker than
light.’ Gent. 10 fin. S. Hippolytus, ‘Whom God the
Father, willing, βουληθείς, begat as He willed, ὡς ἠθέλησεν. contr. Noet. 16. Origen, ἐκ
θελήματος. ap. Justin. ad. Menn. vid. also cum filius
charitatis etiam voluntatis. Periarch. iv. 28. were to say
this in simplicity, there would be
no cause to be suspicious of the expression, the right intention διανοίας interpretation, §26, n. 9. prevailing over that somewhat simple use of
words Cf.
Ep. Æg. 8. and supr. ii. 3. Also Letter 54
fin. Vid. supr. de Decr. 10, n. 3. And vid. Leont. contr.
Nest. iii. 41. (p. 581. Canis.) He here seems alluding to the
Semi-Arians, Origen, and perhaps the earlier Fathers.. But since the phrase is from the heretics Tatian had said θελήματι
προπηδᾷ ὁ
λόγος. Gent.
5. Tertullian had said, ‘Ut primum voluit Deus ea edere, ipsum
primum protulit sermonem. adv. Prax. 6. Novatian, Ex quo, quando
ipse voluit, Sermo filius natus est. de Trin. 31. And Constit.
Apost. τὸν
πρὸ αἰ& 240·νων
εὐδοκί& 139·
τοῦ πατρὸς
γεννηθέντα. vii. 41. Pseudo-Clem. Genuit Deus voluntate
præcedente. Recognit. iii. 10. Eusebius, κατὰ
γνώμην καὶ
προαίρεσιν
βουληθεὶς ὁ
θεός· ἐκ τῆς
τοῦ πατρὸς
βουλῆς καὶ
δυνάμεως. Dem. iv. 3. Arius, θελήματι
καὶ βουλῇ
ὑπέστη. ap.
Theod. H. E. i. 4. p. 750. vid. also de Syn.
16. and the words of heretics are suspicious,
and, as it is written, ‘The wicked are deceitful,’ and
‘The words of the wicked are deceit Prov. xii. 5,
6.
LXX.,’ even though they but make signs De
Decr. 20., for their heart is depraved, come let us
examine this phrase also, lest, though convicted on all sides, still,
as hydras, they invent a fresh word, and by such clever language and
specious evasion, they sow again that irreligion of theirs in another
way. For he who says, ‘The Son came to be at the Divine
will,’ has the same meaning as another who says, ‘Once He
was not,’ and ‘The Son came to be out of nothing,’
and ‘He is a creature.’ But since they are now ashamed of
these phrases, these crafty ones have endeavoured to convey their
meaning in another way, putting forth the word ‘will,’ as
cuttlefish their blackness, thereby to blind the simple p.
69. n. 8., and to keep in mind their peculiar heresy.
For whence And
so supr. de Decr. 18, ‘by what Saint have they been taught
“at will?”’ That is, no one ever taught it in the
sense in which they explained it; that he has just said,
‘He who says “at will” has the same meaning as he who
says “Once He was not.”’ Cf. below §§61,
64, 66. Certainly as the earlier Fathers had used the phrase, so those
who came after Arius. Thus Nyssen in the passage in contr.
Eun. vii. referred to in the next note. And Hilar. Syn.
37. The same father says, unitate Patris et virtute. Psalm xci.
8.
and ut voluit, ut potuit, ut scit qui genuit. Trin. iii. 4. And
he addresses Him as non invidum bonorum tuorum in Unigeniti tui
nativitate. ibid. vi. 21. S. Basil too speaks of our Lord as
αὐτοζωὴν
καὶ
αὐτοάγαθον, ‘from the quickening Fountain, the Father’s
goodness, ἀγαθότητος.’ contr. Eun. ii. 25. And
Cæsarius calls Him ἀγάπην
πατρός.
Quæst. 39. Vid. Ephrem. Syr. adv. Scrut. R. vi. 1.
Oxf. Tra. and note there. Maximus Taurin. says, that God is per
omnipotentiam Pater. Hom. de trad. Symb. p. 270. ed. 1784, vid.
also Chrysol. Serm. 61. Ambros. de Fid. iv. 8. Petavius
refers in addition to such passages as one just quoted from S. Hilary,
which speak of God as not invidus, so as not to communicate Himself,
since He was able. Si non potuit, infirmus; si non voluit, invidus.
August. contr. Maxim. iii. 7. bring they ‘by will and
pleasure?’ or from what Scripture? let them say, who are so
suspicious in their words and so inventive of irreligion. For the
Father who revealed from heaven His own Word, declared, ‘This is
My beloved Son;’ and by David He said, ‘My heart uttered a
good Word;’ and John He bade say, ‘In the beginning was the
Word;’ and David says in the Psalm, ‘With Thee is the well
of life, and in Thy light shall we see light;’ and the Apostle
writes, ‘Who being the Radiance of Glory,’ and again,
‘Who being in the form of God,’ and, ‘Who is the
Image of the invisible God Matt. iii. 17; Ps. xlv.
1; John i. 1; Ps. xxxvi. 9; Heb. i. 3; Phil. ii. 26; Col. i.
15..’