Chapter 3.—4. There are two propositions, moreover, which we affirm,—that baptism
exists in the Catholic Church, and that in it alone can it be rightly received,—both of which
the Donatists deny. Likewise there are two other propositions which we affirm,—that baptism
exists among the Donatists, but that with them it is not rightly received, of which two they
strenuously confirm the former, that baptism exists with them; but they are unwilling to
allow the latter, that in their Church it cannot be rightly received. Of these four propositions,
three are peculiar to us; in one we both agree. For that baptism exists in the Catholic Church,
that it is rightly received there, and that it is not rightly received among the Donatists, are
assertions made only by ourselves; but that baptism exists also among the Donatists, is as-
serted by them and allowed by us. If any one, therefore, is desirous of being baptized, and
is already convinced that he ought to choose our Church as a medium for Christian salvation,
and that the baptism of Christ is only profitable in it, even when it has been received else-
where, but yet wishes to be baptized in the schism of Donatus, because not they only, nor
we only, but both parties alike say that baptism exists with them, let him pause and look to
the other three points. For if he has made up his mind to follow us in the points which they
deny, though he prefers what both of us acknowledge, to what only we assert, it is enough
for our purpose that he prefers what they do not affirm and we alone assert, to what they
alone assert. That baptism exists in the Catholic Church, we assert and they deny. That it
is rightly received in the Catholic Church, we assert and they deny. That it is not rightly
received in the schism of Donatus, we assert and they deny. As, therefore, he is the more
ready to believe what we alone assert should be believed, so let him be the more ready to do
what we alone declare should be done. But let him believe more firmly, if he be so disposed,
what both parties assert should be believed, than what we alone maintain. For he is inclined
to believe more firmly that the baptism of Christ exists in the schism of Donatus, because
that is acknowledged by both of us, than that it exists in the Catholic Church, an assertion
made alone by the Catholics. But again, he is more ready to believe that the baptism of
Christ exists also with us, as we alone assert, than that it does not exist with us, as they alone
assert. For he has already determined and is fully convinced, that where we differ, our au-
thority is to be preferred to theirs. So that he is more ready to believe what we alone assert,
that baptism is rightly received with us, than that it is not rightly so received, since that rests
only on their assertion. And, by the same rule, he is more ready to believe what we alone
assert, that it is not rightly received with them, than as they alone assert, that it is rightly so
received. He finds, therefore, that his confidence in being baptized among the Donatists is
somewhat profitless, seeing that, though we both acknowledge that baptism exists with
them, yet we do not both declare that it ought to be received from them. But he has made
up his mind to cling rather to us in matters where we disagree. Let him therefore feel con-
fidence in receiving baptism in our communion, where he is assured that it both exists and
is rightly received; and let him not receive it in a communion, where those whose opinion
Chapter 3
701
Chapter 3