even granting that there are atoms, and that these strike and shake each other by clashing
together as chance may guide them, is it lawful for us to grant also that atoms thus meeting
in fortuitous concourse can so make anything as to fashion its distinctive forms, determine
its figure, polish its surface, enliven it with color, or quicken it by imparting to it a spirit?—all
which things every one sees to be accomplished in no other way than by the providence of
God, if only he loves to see with the mind rather than with the eye alone, and asks this faculty
of intelligent perception from the Author of his being. Nay, more; we are not at liberty even
to grant the existence of atoms themselves, for, without discussing the subtle theories of the
learned as to the divisibility of matter, observe how easily the absurdity of atoms may be
proved from their own opinions. For they, as is well known, affirm that there is nothing else
in nature but bodies and empty space, and the accidents of these, by which I believe that
they mean motion and striking, and the forms which result from these. Let them tell us,
then, under which category they reckon the images which they suppose to flow from the
more solid bodies, but which, if indeed they are bodies, possess so little solidity that they
are not discernible except by their contact with the eyes when we see them, and with the
mind when we think of them. For the opinion of these philosophers is, that these images
can proceed from the material object and come to the eyes or to the mind, which, neverthe-
less, they affirm to be material. Now, I ask, do these images flow from atoms themselves? If
they do, how can these be atoms from which some bodily particles are in this process separ-
ated? If they do not, either something can be the object of thought without such images,
which they vehemently deny, or we ask, whence have they acquired a knowledge of atoms,
seeing that they can in nowise become objects of thought to us? But I blush to have even
thus far refuted these opinions, although they did not blush to hold them. When, however,
I consider that they have even dared to defend them, I blush not on their account, but for
the race of mankind itself whose ears could tolerate such nonsense.
Chap. V.
32. Wherefore, seeing that the minds of men are, through the pollution of sin and the
lust of the flesh, so blinded that even these monstrous errors could waste in discussion
concerning them the leisure of learned men, will you, Dioscorus, or will any man of an servant
mind, hesitate to affirm that in no way could better provision have been made for the pursuit
of truth by mankind than that a Man, assumed into ineffable and miraculous union by the
Truth Himself, and being the manifestation of His Person on the earth, should by perfect
teaching and divine acts move men to saving faith in that which could not as yet be intellec-
tually apprehended? To the glory of Him who has done this we give our service; and we
exhort you to believe immoveably and stedfastly in Him through whom it has come to pass
that not a select few, but whole peoples, unable to discern these things by reason, do accept
972
To Dioscorus