Elucidations.
————————————
I.
(Teaching of the Church, p. 240.)
It
is noteworthy how frequently
our author employs this expression in this immediate connection.
Concerning the punishment of the wicked he asserts a “clearly
defined teaching.” He shows what the Church’s
teaching “has laid down” touching demons and angels.
Touching the origin of the world, he again asserts the Church’s
teaching, and then concedes, that, over and above what he maintains,
there is “no clear statement regarding it,”—i.e., the
creation and its antecedents. Elsewhere he speaks of “the
faith of the Church,” and all this as something accepted by all
Christians recognised as orthodox or Catholics.
Not to recur to the subject of the creeds
3013
known at this period in the East and West,
this frequent recognition of a system of theology, or something like
it, starts some interesting inquiries. We have space to state
only some of them:—
1. Was Origen here speaking of the catechetical
school of Alexandria, and assuming its teaching to be that of the whole
Church?
2. If so, was not this recognition of the
Alexandrian leadership the precursor of that terrible shock which was
given to Christendom by the rise of Arianism out of such a stronghold
of orthodoxy?
3. Does not the power of Athanasius to stand
“against the world” assure us that he was strong in the
position that “the teaching of the Church,” in Alexandria
and elsewhere, was against Arias, whom he was able to defeat by
prescription
as well as by Scripture?
4. Is it not clear that all this was
asserted, held, and defined without help from the West, and that the
West merely responded
Amen
to what Alexandria had taught from
the beginning?
5. Is not the evidence overwhelming, that nothing
but passive testimony was thus far heard of in connection with the see
of Rome?
6. If the “teaching of the Church,”
then, was so far independent of that see that Christendom neither
waited for its voice, nor recognised it as of any exceptional
importance in the definition of the faith and the elimination of
heresy, is it not evident that the entire fabric of the Middle-Age
polity in the West has its origin in times and manners widely differing
from the Apostolic Age and that of the Ante-Nicene Fathers?
II.
(Subjection, p. 343.)
The
subordination
of the Son, as held by
all Nicene Christians, is defended by Bull
3014
at
great length and with profound learning. It is my purpose
elsewhere to quote his splendid tribute to the substantial orthodoxy of
Origen. Professor Shedd, in his work on
Christian
Doctrine
,
3015
pronounces the
Nicene Creed “
the received
creed-statement among all
Trinitarian Churches.” I assume that this note will be of
interest to all theological minds. For an unsatisfactory and
meagre account of primitive creeds, see Bunsen,
Hippol
., iii.
pp. 125–132.
III.
(Proceedeth from the Father, p. 344.)
The double procession is no part of the Creed of
Christendom; nor did it become fixed in the West, till, by the
influence of Charlemagne, the important but not immaculate Council of
Frankfort (
a.d.
794) completed the work of
Toledo, and committed the whole West to its support. The Anglican
Church recites the
Filioque
liturgically, but explains its
adhesion to this
formula
in a manner satisfactory to the
Easterns. It has no rightful place in the Creed, however; and its
retention in the Nicene Symbol is a just offence, not only to the
Greeks, but against the great canon,
Quod semper
,
etc.
Compare Pearson on the
Creed
,
3016
and these candid words:
“Although the addition of words to the formal Creed
be not
justifiable
,” etc. Consult the valuable work of
Theophanes Procopowicz, Bishop of Novgorod, which contains a history of
the literature of the subject down to his times.
3017
It is a matter debated anew in our own
age, in view of advances to the Greeks made by Dr. Döllinger and
the Old Catholics. Let me refer to a volume almost equally
learned and ill-digested,
3018
written by a clever
author who was perverted to Romanism, and returned, after many years,
to the Church of England. It bears the marks of many unreal
impressions received during his “Babylonish
captivity.” I refer to a work of E. S. Foulkes.
IV.
(The faith of the Church, p. 347.)
Before the Nicene Council local creeds were in
use, all agreeing substantially; all scriptural, but some more full
than others. Of these the ancient Symbol of Jerusalem was chief,
and this forms the base of the Nicene Creed. It is here
noteworthy that Origen speaks of “the faith” as something
settled and known: clearly, he did not intentionally transgress
it. Bull says,
3019
“Græci
Scriptores Ante-Nicæni
τὸν κανόνα
τῆς πίστεως
passim in scriptis suis commemorant.” See the
Jerusalem Creed, on the same page; and note, the Church of Jerusalem is
called by the Second Œcumenical Council (
a.d.
381), “the mother of all the
Churches.” So ignorant were the Fathers of that date of any
other “mother Church,” that they address this very
statement to the clergy of Rome.
3020
Compare
Eusebius, book iv. cap. viii.
V.
(Endowed with freedom of will, p. 347.)
Elsewhere in this treatise our author defines the
will as “able to resist external causes.” The
profound work of Edwards needs no words of mine.
3021
As an example of logic the most acute,
it is the glory of early American literature. I read it eagerly
during my college course, while under the guidance of my instructor in
philosophy, the amiable and profound Dr. Tappan (afterwards president
of the University of Michigan), who taught us to admire it, but not to
regard it as infallible. See his vigorous review of
Edwards,
3022
in which he argues
as a disciple of Coleridge and of Plato.
On allied subjects, let me refer to Wiggers’s
Augustinismus
, etc., translated by Professor Emerson of
Andover;
3023
also to
Bledsoe’s
Theodicy
,
3024
heretofore cited. I venture to say, that, among the thinkers of
America, and as Christian philosophers, both Bledsoe and Tappan are
less known and honoured than they deserve to be.
VI.
(Not esteemed authoritative by all, p. 379.)
Not by Jerome, nor Rufinus, nor Chrysostom.
Gregory the Great, Bishop of Rome, is also shown by Lardner
(
Credib
., v. 127) to have quoted “the wisdom of
Solomon” only as the sayings of a wise man; not at all as
Scripture. The Easterns are equally represented by John Damascene
(
a.d.
730), who says of this book that it is
one of those “excellent and useful” books which are not
reckoned with the hagiographa. But Methodius is an exception; for
he quotes this book
twice
(says Lardner) as if it were
Scripture, and certainly cites it not infrequently. Yet his
testimony does not amount, perhaps, to more than an acceptance of the
same as only
deutero-canonical
; i.e., as one of the books
read in the Church for instruction, but not appealed to as establishing
any doctrine otherwise unknown to the Church. We may examine this
subject when we come to Methodius, in vol. vi. of this series.
————————————
Note.
This
is a convenient place
for the following tables, compiled from Eusebius as far as his history
goes; i.e.
a.d
. 305. See also Dr.
Robinson’s
Researches
.
I.
The See of
Jerusalem
.
1. James, the Lord’s brother.
2. Simeon.
3. Justus.
4. Zacchæus.
5. Tobias.
6. Benjamin.
7. John.
8. Matthew.
9. Philip.
10. Seneca.
11. Justus.
12. Levi.
13. Ephres.
14. Joseph.
15. Judah.
16. Marcus.
17. Cassian.
18. Publius.
19. Maximus.
20. Julian.
21. Caius.
22. Symmachus.
23. Caius II.
24. Julian II.
25. Capito.
26. Maximus II.
27. Antoninus.
28. Valens.
29. Dolichianus.
30. Narcissus.
31. Dius.
32. Germanio.
33. Gordius.
34. Narcissus II.
35. Alexander.
36. Mazabanes.
37. Hymenæus.
38. Zabdas.
39. Hermon,
a.d.
300.
II.
The See of
Alexandria
.
1. Annianus.
2. Avilius.
3. Cerdon.
4. Primus.
5. Justus.
6. Eumenes.
7. Marcus.
8. Celadion.
9. Aggripinus.
10. Julianus.
11. Demetrius.
12. Heraclas.
13. Dionysius.
14. Maximus.
15. Theonas.
16. Peter.
17. Achillas.
18. Alexander,
3025
a.d.
326.
3013
On which consult
Dupin, and, for another view, Bunsen’s
Hippolytus
.
See also p. 383,
infra
.
3014
Vol. v. p. 134, and
passim
to 745; also vi. 368.
3015
Vol. ii. p. 438.
3016
pp. 521–526.
3017
Tractatus de
Processione Spiritus Sancti
, Gothæ,
a.d.
1772.
3018
Christendom’s
Divisions
, London, 1865.
3019
Vol. vi. p. 132,
133.
3020
Theodoret, book v.
cap. ix.
3021
Ed. Converse, New
York, 1829.
3022
A Review of
Edward’s Inquiry
, by Henry Philip Tappan, New York, 1839.
3023
New York, 1840.
3024
New York, 1854.
See vol. ii. p. 522, this series.
3025
Alexander, dying just
after the Nicene Council, was succeeded by the great Athanasius.