3. Further, Bull gives us no proof whatever that
the Semi-arians did deny the ἐξ οὐσίας; while
it is very clear, if it is right to contradict so great a writer, that
most of them did not deny it. He says that it is
“certissimum” that the heretics who wrote the three
confessions above noticed, that is, the Semi-arians, “nunquam
fassos, nunquam fassuros fuisse filium ἐξ
οὐσίας, e substantia, Patris
progenitum.” His reason for not offering any proof for this
naturally is, that Petavius, with whom he is in controversy, maintains
it also, and he makes use of Petavius’s admission against
himself. Now it may seem bold in a writer of this day to differ not
only with Bull, but with Petavius; but the reason for doing so is
simple; it is because Athanasius asserts the very thing which Petavius
and Bull deny, and Petavius admits that he does; that is, he allows it
by implication when he complains that Athanasius had not got to the
bottom of the doctrine of the Semi-arians, and thought too favourably
of them. “Horum Semi-arianorum, quorum antesignanus fuit Basilius
Ancyræ episcopus, prorsus obscura fuit hæresis..…ut ne
ipse quidem Athanasius satis illam exploratam habuerit.” de
Trin. i. x. §7.