iv. Supposed learning of Antony. His ignorance of
letters and of the Greek language does not prevent his forcibly
employing the most effective arguments against Arianism (69),
vindicating the Incarnation (74) much in the manner of Athanasius, and
above all showing a fair acquaintance (72–74) with Platonic
philosophy (see notes there). But everything in the biography points to
a man of robust mind, retentive memory (3) and frequent intercourse
with visitors. If he were so, he can scarcely have been ignorant of the
theological controversies of his day, or of the current philosophical
ideas. Nor can I see that the philosophy of his argument against the
Greeks goes beyond what that would imply. His allusion to Plato does
not look like a first-hand citation. And even an Athanasius would not
so entirely rise out of the biographical habits of his day as to mingle
nothing of his own with the speeches of his hero (‘Equidem quid
Antonio quid Athanasio tribuendum sit uix diiudicari posse
concedo,’ Eich. p. 52).