the very fact that they alone, of all the theologians of the first six centuries, became the cre-
ators of distinct systems, each proceeding from a definite idea, and each completely carried
out; and this fact proves also how much the one system has that is analogous to the other.
The one system, like the other, is founded upon the idea of freedom; in both there is a spe-
cific act, by which the entire development of human life is determined; and in both this is
an act which lies far outside of the temporal consciousness of the individual; with this dif-
ference alone, that in one system the act belongs to each separate individual himself, and
only falls outside of his temporal life and consciousness; in the other, it lies within the sphere
of the temporal history of man, but is only the act of one individual. If in the system of
Origen nothing gives greater offence than the idea of the pre-existence and fall of souls,
which seems to adopt heathen ideas into the Christian faith, there is in the system of Augustin
the same overleaping of individual life and consciousness, in order to explain from an act
in the past the present sinful condition of man; but the pagan Platonic point of view is ex-
changed for one taken from the Old Testament.…What therefore essentially distinguishes
the system of Augustin from that of Origen, is only this: the fall of Adam is substituted for
the pre-temporal fall of souls, and what in Origen still wears a heathen garb, puts on in
Augustin a purely Old Testament form.”
The learning of Augustin was not equal to his genius, nor as extensive as that of Origen
and Eusebius, but still considerable for his time, and superior to that of any of the Latin
fathers, with the single exception of Jerome. He had received in the schools of Madaura and
Carthage the usual philosophical and rhetorical preparation for the forum, which stood him
in good stead also in theology. He was familiar with Latin literature, and was by no means
blind to the excellencies of the classics, though he placed them far below the higher beauty
of the Holy Scriptures. The Hortensius of Cicero (a lost work) inspired him during his uni-
versity course with enthusiasm for philosophy and for the knowledge of truth for its own
sake; the study of Platonic and Neo-Platonic works (in the Latin version of the rhetorician
Victorinus) kindled in him an incredible fire22; though in both he missed the holy name of
Jesus and the cardinal virtues of love and humility, and found in them only beautiful ideals
9
without power to conform him to them. His City of God, his book on heresies, and other
writings, show an extensive knowledge of ancient philosophy, poetry, and history, sacred
and secular. He refers to the most distinguished persons of Greece and Rome; he often alludes
to Pythagoras, Plato, Aristotle, Plotin, Porphyry, Cicero, Seneca, Horace, Vergil, to the
earlier Greek and Latin fathers, to Eastern and Western heretics. But his knowledge of Greek
literature was mostly derived from Latin translations. With the Greek language, as he himself
22 Adv. Academicos, 1. ii. c. 2, § 5: “Etiam mihi ipsi de me incredibile incendium concitarunt.” And in several
passages of the Civitas Dei (viii. 3–12 xxii. 27) he speaks very favourably of Plato, and also of Aristotle, and thus
broke the way for the high authority of the Aristotelian philosophy with the scholastics of the middle age.
21
Estimate of St. Augustin