Let us, if you please, examine
his irrefragable syllogisms, and his subtle transpositions Transpositions of the terms in his own false premises;
τῶν
σοφισμάτων
ἀντιστροφὰς. The same as “the professional twisting of
premisses,” and “the hooking backward and forward and
twisting of premisses” below. The terms Father and ᾽Αγέννητος
are transposed or twisted into each other’s
place in this ‘irrefragable syllogism.’ It is ‘a
reductio ad absurdum’ thus:—
Father means ᾽Αγέννητος
(Basil’s premiss),
∴ ᾽Αγέννητος
means Father.
The fallacy of Eunomius consists
in making ‘Father’ universal in his own premiss, when it
was only particular in Basil’s. “᾽Αγέννητος
means the whole contents of the word
Father,” which therefore cannot mean having generated a son. It
is a False Conversion.
This Conversion or ἀντιοτροφὴ
is illustrated in Aristotle’s Analytics,
Prior. I. iii. 3. It is legitimate thus:—
Some B is A
∴ Some A is (some) B. of the terms in his own false premisses, by
which he hopes to shake that argument; though, indeed, I fear lest the
miserable quibbling in what he says may in a measure raise a prejudice
also against the remarks that would correct it. When striplings
challenge to a fight, men get more blame for pugnaciousness in closing
with such foes, than honour for their show of victory. Nevertheless,
what we want to say is this. We think, indeed, that the things said by
him, with that well-known elocution now familiar to us, only for the
sake of being insolent, are better buried in silence and oblivion; they
may suit him; but to us they afford only an exercise for much-enduring
patience. Nor would it be proper, I think, to insert his ridiculous
expressions in the midst of our own serious controversy, and so to make
this zeal for the truth evaporate in coarse, vulgar laughter; for
indeed to be within hearing, and to remain unmoved, is an
impossibility, when he says with such sublime and magnificient
verbosity, “Where additional words amount to additional
blasphemy, it is by half as much more tranquillizing to be silent than
to speak.” Let those laugh at these expressions who know which of
them are fit to be believed, and which only to be laughed at; while we
scrutinize the keenness of those syllogisms with which he tries to tear
our system to pieces.