Upon the historic truth of Peter’s visit to Rome, see below,
chap. 25, note 7. Although we may accept it as certain that he did
visit Rome, and that he met his death there, it is no less certain that
he did not reach there until late in the reign of Nero. The tradition
that he was for twenty-five years bishop of Rome is first recorded by
Jerome (de vir. ill. c. 1), and since his time has been almost
universally accepted in the Roman Catholic Church, though in recent
years many more candid scholars of that communion acknowledge that so
long an episcopate there is a fiction. The tradition undoubtedly took
its rise from the statement of Justin Martyr (quoted in the previous
chapter) that Simon Magus came to Rome during the reign of Claudius.
Tradition, in the time of Eusebius, commonly connected the Roman visits
of Simon and of Peter; and consequently Eusebius, accepting the earlier
date for Simon’s arrival in Rome, quite naturally assumed also
the same date for Peter’s arrival there, although Justin does not
mention Peter in connection with Simon in the passage which Eusebius
quotes. The assumption that Peter took up his residence in Rome during
the reign of Claudius contradicts all that we know of Peter’s
later life from the New Testament and from other early writers. In 44
a.d. he was in Jerusalem (according to
Acts xii.
3);
in 51 he was again there (according to Acts xv.); and a little
later in Antioch (according to Gal. i. 11 sq.). Moreover,
at some time during his life he labored in various provinces in Asia
Minor, as we learn from his first epistle, and probably wrote that
epistle from Babylon on the Euphrates (see chap. 15, note 7). At any
rate, he cannot have been in Rome when Paul wrote his epistle to the
Romans (57 or 58 a.d.), for no mention is made
of him among the brethren to whom greetings are sent. Nor can he have
been there when Paul wrote from Rome during his captivity (61 or 62 to
63 or 64 a.d.). We have, in fact, no trace of
him in Rome, except the extra-Biblical but well-founded tradition (see
chap. 25, note 7) that he met his death there. We may assume, then,
that he did not reach Rome at any rate until shortly before his death;
that is, shortly before the summer of 64 a.d.
As most of the accounts put Simon Magus’ visit to Rome in the
reign of Nero (see above, chap. 13, note 9), so they make him follow
Peter thither (as he had followed him everywhere, opposing and
attacking him), instead of precede him, as Eusebius does. Eusebius
follows Justin in giving the earlier date for Simon’s visit to
Rome; but he goes beyond Justin in recording his encounter there with
Peter, which neither Justin nor Irenæus mentions. The earlier date
for Simon’s visit is undoubtedly that given by the oldest
tradition. Afterward, when Peter and Paul were so prominently connected
with the reign of Nero, the visit of Simon was postponed to synchronize
with the presence of the two apostles in Rome. A report of
Simon’s meeting with Peter in Rome is given first by Hippolytus
(VI. 15); afterward by Arnobius (II. 12), who does not describe the
meeting; by the Ap. Const., the Clementine Recognitions
and Homilies, and the Acts of the Apostles Peter and
Paul. It is impossible to tell from what source Eusebius drew his
information. Neither Justin, Irenæus, nor Tertullian mentions it.
Hippolytus and Arnobius and the App. Const. give too much, as
they give accounts of his death, which Eusebius does not follow. As to
this, it might, however, be said that these accounts are so conflicting
that Eusebius may have omitted them entirely, while yet recording the
meeting. Still, if he had read Hippolytus, he could hardly have omitted
entirely his interesting account. Arnobius and Tertullian, who wrote in
Latin, he did not read, and the Clementines were probably too late for
him; at any rate, they cannot have been the source of his account,
which differs entirely from theirs. It is highly probable, therefore,
that he followed Justin and Irenæus as far as they go, and that he
recorded the meeting with Peter in Rome as a fact commonly accepted in
his time, and one for which he needed no written authority; or it is
possible that he had another source, unknown to us, as suggested above
(note 4).