(c) We must now take account of the party headed
by Basil of Ancyra
and usually (since Epiphanius), but with some injustice, designated as
Semi-Arians. Their theological ancestry and
antecedents have been already sketched (pp. xxvii., xxxv.); they are
the representatives of that conservatism, moulded by the neo-Asiatic,
or modified Origenist tradition, which warmly condemned Arianism at
Nicæa, but acquiesced with only half a heart in the test by which
the Council resolved to exclude it. They furnished the numerical
strength, the material basis so to call it, of the anti-Nicene
reaction; but the reaction on their part had not been Arian in
principle, but in part anti-Sabellian, in part the empirical
conservatism of men whose own principles are vague and ill-assorted,
and who fail to follow the keener sight which distinguishes the higher
conservatism from the lower. They lent themselves to the purposes of
the Eusebians (a name which ought to be dropped after 342) on purely
negative grounds and in view of questions of personal rights and
accusations. A positive doctrinal formula they did not possess. But in
the course of years reflexion did its work. A younger generation grew
up who had not been taught to respect Nicæa, nor yet had imbibed
Arian principles. Cyril at Jerusalem, Meletius at Antioch, are
specimens of a large class. The Dedication Creed at Antioch represents
an early stage in the growth of this body of conviction, conviction not
absolutely uniform everywhere, as the result shews, but still with a
distinct tendency to settle down to a formal position with regard to
the great question of the age. There was nothing in the Nicene
doctrine that men like this did not hold: but the word
ὁμοούσιον
opened the door to the dreaded Sabellian error: was not the history of
Marcellus and Photinus a significant comment upon it? But if οὐσία meant not
individuality, but specific identity (supr., p. xxxi.
sq.) even this term might be innocently admitted. But to make
that meaning plain, what was more effective than the insertion of an
iota? ῾Ομοιούσιος,
then, was the satisfactory test which would banish Arius and Marcellus
alike. Who first used the word for the purpose, we do not know, but its
first occurrence is its prohibition in the ‘blasphemy’ of
Valens in 357. The leader of the ‘semi-Arians’ in 357 was
Basil of Ancyra, a man of deep learning and high character. George of
Laodicea, an original Arian, was in active but short-lived Apparently it began with the quarrel over the election to the
bishopric of Antioch, which Eudoxius managed to seize after the death
of Leontius. George was aggrieved at his rights as an elector being
ignored, and may have had hopes of the see for himself. See Soz. iv.
13; but Philost. iv. 5 with much less likelihood puts this down to
Basil. alliance with the party, other prominent
members of it were Eustathius, Bishop of Sebaste (Sivas), Eleusius of
Cyzicus, Macedonius of Constantinople, Eusebius of Emesa, Cyril of
Jerusalem, and Mark of Arethusa, a high-minded but violent man, who
represents the ‘left’ wing of the party as Cyril and Basil
represent the ‘right.’