The discussion now turns to the words of Pelagius’
book. “All are ruled by their own will” (27). No; for
Christ says, “I came not to do My own will.” “The
wicked shall not be spared in the judgment.” But we must
distinguish between the impious or heretics who will be destroyed (28)
and Christian sinners who will be forgiven. Some of his sayings
contradict each other or are trifling (29, 30). “The kingdom of
heaven is promised in the Old Testament.” Yes, but more fully in
the New. Returning to the first thesis, “That a man can be
without sin if he wills it,” the Pelagian says, If things, like
desires which arise spontaneously and have no issue, are reckoned
blamable, we charge the sin on our Maker; to which it is only answered
that, though we cannot understand God’s ways, we must not arraign
His justice. In the rest of the book, Atticus alone speaks, going
through the Old Testament, and showing that each of the saints falls
into some sin, which, though done in ignorance or half-consciousness,
yet brings condemnation with it.