The fourth Discourse, as
has been already observed (p. 304), stands on a footing of its own. To
begin with, it is not quoted in antiquity, as the first three are, as
part of the work of Ath. against the Arians (details in Newman, p.
499). Again, the fact that not only the Ep. Æg., but even
the dubious de Incar. c. Arian., are in some mss. included in the Orationes, while our present
oration appears sometimes as the ‘fifth’ sometimes as the
‘sixth,’ cast a shade of doubt upon its claim to be
included in the ‘Pentabiblus against the Arians’ referred
to by Photius. In addition to these external considerations, Newman
lays stress on the apparent want of continuity in its argument; on its
non-conformity to the structural plan of Orat. i.–iii., on
the use of the term ὁμοούσιον
(§§10, 22, contrast Orat. i. §9, p. 311, note
12); on certain peculiarities of style which seem characteristic of
disjointed notes rather than of a systematic treatise; on the reference
to ‘Eusebius’ (of Cæsarea) as apparently still living
(§8); and on the general absence of personal reference to
opponents, while yet a definite and extant system seems to be
combated.