The
tradition that Peter suffered martyrdom in Rome is as old and as
universal as that in regard to Paul, but owing to a great amount of
falsehood which became mixed with the original tradition by the end of
the second century the whole has been rejected as untrue by some modern
critics, who go so far as to deny that Peter was ever at Rome. (See
especially Lipsius’ Die Quellen der römischen
Petrus-Sage, Kiel, 1872; a summary of his view is given by Jackson
in the Presbyterian Quarterly and Princeton Review, 1876, p. 265
sq. In Lipsius’ latest work upon this subject, Die Acta Pauli
und Petri, 1887, he makes important concessions.) The tradition is,
however, too strong to be set aside, and there is absolutely no trace
of any conflicting tradition. We may therefore assume it as
overwhelmingly probable that Peter was in Rome and suffered martyrdom
there. His martyrdom is plainly referred to in John xxi. 10, though the place
of it is not given. The first extra-biblical witness to it is Clement
of Rome. He also leaves the place of the martyrdom unspecified (Ad
Cor. 5), but he evidently assumes the place as well known, and
indeed it is impossible that the early Church could have known of the
death of Peter and Paul without knowing where they died, and there is
in neither case a single opposing tradition. Ignatius (Ad Rom.
chap. 4) connects Paul and Peter in an especial way with the Roman
Church, which seems plainly to imply that Peter had been in Rome.
Phlegon (supposed to be the Emperor Hadrian writing under the name of a
favorite slave) is said by Origen (Contra Celsum, II. 14) to
have confused Jesus and Peter in his Chronicles. This is very
significant as implying that Peter must have been well known in Rome.
Dionysius, quoted below, distinctly states that Peter labored in Rome,
and Caius is a witness for it. So Irenæus, Clement, Tertullian,
and later Fathers without a dissenting voice. The first to mention
Peter’s death by crucifixion (unless John xxi. 18 be supposed to
imply it) is Tertullian (De Præscrip. Hær. chap. 36),
but he mentions it as a fact already known, and tradition since his
time is so unanimous in regard to it that we may consider it in the
highest degree probable. On the tradition reported by Origen, that
Peter was crucified head downward, see below, Bk. III. chap. 1, where
Origen is quoted by Eusebius.