confusion in regard to the various Antonines (see especially the note on the preface to Book
V.) is not at all unusual among the writers of his day, and in view of the frequent and per-
plexing use of the same names by the different emperors, might be quite excusable in a less
scholarly man than Eusebius, but in his case it is evidence of unpardonable want of care.
This serious defect in our author’s method is not peculiar to him. Many historians, critical
almost to a fault in most matters, accept the received chronology without question, and
build upon it as if it were the surest of foundations. Such a consideration does not excuse
Eusebius; it relieves him, however, of the stigma of peculiarity.
Finally, the character of the History is greatly impaired by our author’s desultory
method. This is a characteristic of his literary work in general, and was referred to in the
previous chapter. All his works are marred by it, but few suffer more noticeably than the
History. The author does not confine himself as strictly as he should to the logical limits of
the subject which he is treating, but allows himself to be led away from the main point by
the suggestions that pour in upon him from all sides. As Lightfoot remarks, “We have not
unfrequently to pick out from various parts of his work the notices bearing on one definite
and limited subject. He relates a fact, or quotes an authority bearing upon it, in season or
out of season, according as it is recalled to his memory by some accidental connexion.” This
unfortunate habit of Eusebius’ is one into which men of wide learning are very apt to fall.
The richness of their acquisitions embarrasses them, and the immense number of facts in
their possession renders a comprehension of them all into one logical whole very difficult;
and yet unless the facts be thus comprehended, unless they be thoroughly digested and ar-
ranged, the result is confusion and obscurity. To exclude is as necessary as to include, if one
would write history with the highest measure of success; to exclude rigidly at one time what
it is just as necessary to include at another. To men like Eusebius there is perhaps nothing
more difficult than this. Only a mind as intensive as it is extensive, with a grasp as strong
as its reach is wide, can accomplish it, and few are the minds that are blessed with both
qualities. Few are the writers whose histories stand upon our shelves that fail not sadly in
the one or in the other; and in few perhaps does the failure seem more marked than in our
author.
And yet, though it is apparent that the value of Eusebius’ work is greatly impaired by
its desultory method of treatment, I am confident that the defect is commonly exaggerated.
The paragraph which Lightfoot quotes from Westcott on this subject leaves a false impression.
Altogether too often our author introduces irrelevant matters, and repeats himself when
repetition “mars the symmetry of his work”; and yet on the whole he follows a fairly well
ordered plan with fairly good success. He endeavors to preserve a strictly chronological se-
quence in his arrangement of the books, and he adheres for the most part to his purpose.
Though there may be disorder and confusion within the various periods, for instance
within the apostolic age, the age of Trajan, of Hadrian, of the Antonines, &c., yet the periods
77
Eusebius as a Historian. The Merits and Defects of his History.