If then they have confidence in their opinions
and statements, let them broach their heresy nakedly, and shew from it
if they think they have any religious argument whether from Scripture,
or from human reason, in their defence. But if they have nothing of the
kind, let them hold their peace. For they will find nothing from any
quarter except the greater condemnation of themselves. Firstly from the
Scriptures, in that John says, ‘In the beginning was the
Word;’ whereas they say, ‘he was not before he was
begotten:’ while David sings, in the character of the Father,
‘my heart uttered a good Word’ (Ps. xlv. 1, LXX), whom they allege to be in thought
only, and originated from nothing. Further, whereas John once more says
in the Gospel (i. 3),
‘all things were made by Him, and without Him was not anything
made,’ while Paul writes, ‘there is one Lord Jesus Christ
by whom are all things’ (1 Cor. viii. 6), and elsewhere, ‘all things were
created in Him’ (Col. i.
16), how will they have the
boldness (or rather how will they escape disgrace) to oppose the
sayings of the saints, by saying that the artificer of all things is a
creature, and that He is a created thing in whom all things created
have come into being and subsist? Nor, secondly, is any religious
argument from human reason left them in their defence. For what man,
Greek or barbarian, presumes to call one, whom he confesses to be God,
a created thing, or to say that he was not before he was made? or what
man, when he has heard Him whom he believes to be God alone say,
‘This is My beloved Son’ (Mat. iii. 17), and ‘my heart uttered a good
Word,’ will venture even to say that the Word out of the heart of
God has come to being out of nothing? or that the Son is a created
thing and not the very offspring of Him that speaks? or again, who that
hears Him whom he believes to be Lord and Saviour say, ‘I am in
the Father and the Father in Me,’ and ‘I and the Father are
one’ (John xiv 10; x.
30), will presume to put
asunder what He has made one and maintained indivisible?