Now the inspired Scripture
teaches us to affirm all these attributes of the Spirit, when it
predicates of the Spirit the terms “good,” and
“wise,” and “incorruptible,” and
“immortal,” and all such lofty conceptions and names as are
properly applied to Godhead. If then He is inferior in none of these
respects, by what means does Eunomius determine the inequality of the
Son and the Spirit? “For the Son is,” he tells us,
“Only-begotten, having no brother begotten with Him.” Well,
the point, that we are not to understand the
“Only-begotten” to have brethren, we have already discussed
in our comments upon the phrase “first-born of all creation See
above, §8 of this book..” But we ought not to leave unexamined
the sense that Eunomius now unfairly attaches to the term. For while
the doctrine of the Church declares that in the Father, the Son, and
the Holy Ghost there is one power, and goodness, and essence, and
glory, and the like, saving the difference of the Persons, this man,
when he wishes to make the essence of the Only-begotten common to the
creation, calls Him “the first-born of all creation” in
respect of His pre-temporal existence, declaring by this mode of
expression that all conceivable objects in creation are in brotherhood
with the Lord; for assuredly the first-born is not the first-born of
those otherwise begotten, but of those begotten like Himself Or,
“not the first-born of beings of a different race, but of those
of his own stock.”. But when he is bent upon severing the Spirit
from union with the Son, he calls Him “Only-begotten, not having
any brother begotten with Him,” not with the object of conceiving
of Him as without brethren, but that by the means of this assertion he
may establish touching the Spirit His essential alienation from the
Son. It is true that we learn from Holy Scripture not to speak of the
Holy Ghost as brother of the Son: but that we are not to say that the
Holy Ghost is homogeneous ὁμογενῆ,
“of the same stock”: the word being the same which (when
coupled with ἀδελφὸν) has been translated, in the passages preceding, by
“begotten with.” with the Son, is
nowhere shown in the divine Scriptures. For if there does reside in the
Father and the Son a life-giving power, it is ascribed also to the Holy
Spirit, according to the words of the Gospel. If one may discern alike
in Father, Son, and Holy Spirit the properties of being incorruptible,
immutable, of admitting no evil, of being good, right, guiding, of
working all in all as He wills, and all the like attributes, how is it
possible by identity in these respects to infer difference in kind?
Accordingly the word of godliness agrees in affirming that we ought not
to regard any kind of brotherhood as attaching to the Only-begotten;
but to say that the Spirit is not homogeneous with the Son, the upright
with the upright, the good with the good, the life-giving with the
life-giving, this has been clearly demonstrated by logical inference to
be a piece of heretical knavery.