4. The Council of Chalcedon refused to consider the Eutychian matter as settled by
Rome’s decision or to accept Leo’s Tome without examination as to whether it was orthodox.
Moreover it passed a canon at a session which the Papal legates refused to attend, ratifying
the order of the Patriarchates fixed at I. Constantinople, and declaring that “the Fathers had
very properly given privileges to Old Rome as the imperial city, and that now they gave the
same (τὰ ἴσα πρεσβεῖα) privileges” to Constantinople as the seat of the imperial government
at that time.
5. The fifth of the Ecumenical Synods refused to receive any written doctrinal commu-
nication from the then pope (Vigilius), took his name from the diptychs, and refused him
communion.
6. The Third Council of Constantinople, the sixth of the Ecumenical Synods, excom-
municated Pope Honorius, who had been dead for years, for holding and teaching the
Monothelite heresy.
7. It is certain that the Pope had nothing to do with the calling of the Seventh Synod,8
and quite possible that it was presided over by Tarasius and not by the Papal legates.
Such is, in brief, the evidence which the Ecumenical Councils give on the subject of
what, for lack of a better designation, may be called the Papal claims. Under these circum-
stances it may not be deemed strange that some extreme ultramontanists have arrived at
the conclusion that much of the acts and decisions as we have them is spurious, or at least
corrupted in an anti-papal direction. Vincenzi, who is the most learned of these writers,
argues somewhat thus “if the members of the Ecumenical Synods believed as we do to-day
with regard to the Papacy it is impossible that they should have acted and spoken as they
did, but we know they must have believed as we do, ergo they did not so act or speak.” The
logic is admirable, but the truth of the conclusion depends upon the truth of the minor
premise. The forgeries would have been very extensive, and who were they done by? For-
geries, as the false decretals, to advance papal claims we are unfortunately familiar with, but
it is hard to imagine who could have forged in Greek and Latin the acts of the Ecumenical
Synods. It is not necessary to pursue the matter any further, perhaps its very mention was
uncalled for, but I wish to be absolutely fair, that no one may say that any evidence has been
suppressed.9
certain, as will be shewn in its proper place). Thus the only two great questions not decided, one way or another,
by the See of Rome before the meeting of a General Council were Arianism and Macedonianism, and some have
held (though mistakenly as is generally thought) that Arius was condemned by a synod held at Rome before
that of Nice.
8 See Michaud’s brilliant answer to Hefele, Discussion sur les Sept Conciles Œcuméniques, p. 327.
9 The reader may easily satisfy himself on this matter by reading the somewhat extensive works of Aloysius
Vincenzi, published in Rome in 1875 and thereabouts.
11
Concerning Ecumenical Councils in General.