95
Concerning Two Souls, Against the Manichæans.
[De Duabus Animabus Contra Manichæos.] a.d. 391.190
___________
One Book.
___________
Chapter 1.—By What Course of Reasoning the Error of the Manichæans Concerning
Two Souls, One of Which is Not from God, is Refuted. Every Soul, Inasmuch as It is a
Certain Life, Can Have Its Existence Only from God the Source of Life.
1. Through the assisting mercy of God, the snares of the Manichæans having been
broken to pieces and left behind, having been restored at length to the bosom of the Catholic
Church, I am disposed now at least to consider and to deplore my recent wretchedness.
For there were many things that I ought to have done to prevent the seeds of the most true
religion wholesomely implanted in me from boyhood, from being banished from my mind,
having been uprooted by the error and fraud of false and deceitful men. For, in the first
place, if I had soberly and diligently considered, with prayerful and pious mind, those two
kinds of souls to which they attributed natures and properties so distinct that they wished
one to be regarded as of the very substance of God, but were not even willing that God
should be accepted as the author of the other; perhaps it would have appeared to me, intent
on learning, that there is no life whatsoever, which, by the very fact of its being life and in
so far as it is life at all, does not pertain to the supreme source and beginning of life,191 which
we must acknowledge to be nothing else than the supreme and only and true God.
Wherefore there is no reason why we should not confess, that those souls which the
Manichæans call evil are either devoid of life and so not souls, neither will anything positively
or negatively, neither follow after nor flee from anything; or, if they live so that they can be
190 Scarcely any one of his earlier treatises was more unsatisfactory to Augustin in his later Anti-Pelagian
years than that Concerning Two Souls. In his Retractations, Book I., chapter xv., he recognizes the rashness of
some of his statements and points out the sense in which they are tenable or the reverse. As regards the occasion
of the writing, the following may be quoted: "After this book [De Utilitate Credendi] I wrote, while still a pres-
byter, against the Manichæans Concerning Two Souls, of which they say that one part is of God, the other from
the race of darkness, which God did not found, and which is coeternal with God, and they rave about both these
souls, the one good, the other evil, being in one man, saying forsooth that the evil soul on the one hand belongs
to the flesh, which flesh also they say is of the race of darkness; but that the good soul is from the part of God
that came forth, combated the race of darkness, and mingled with the latter; and they attribute all good things
in man to that good soul, and all evil things to that evil soul."—A.H.N.]
191 In his Retractations, Augustin explains this proposition as follows: "I said this in the sense in which the
creature is known to pertain to the Creator, but not in the sense that it is of Him, so as to be regarded as part of
Him."—A.H.N.
By What Course of Reasoning the Error of the Manichæans Concerning Two Souls, One of Which is Not from God, is Refuted. Every Soul, Inasmuch as It is a Certain Life, Can Have Its Existence Only from God the Source of Life.
158
By What Course of Reasoning the Error of the Manichæans Concerning Two Souls,…