shadowy phantoms of the departed are often seen. Cf. Origen c. Cels. ii. 60 (in answer to
Celsus’ “Epicurean” opinion that ghosts are pure
illusion): “He who does believe this (i.e. in ghosts)
necessarily believes in the immortality, or at all events the long
continuance of the soul: as Plato does in his treatise on the soul
(i.e. the Phædo) when he says that the shadowy
apparitions of the dead hover round their tombs. These apparitions,
then, have some substance: it is the so-called ‘radiant’
frame in which the soul exists. But Celsus, not liking this, would have
us believe that people have waking dreams and ‘imagine as true,
in accordance with their wishes, a wild piece of unreality.’ In
sleep we may well believe that this is the case: not so in waking
hours, unless some one is quite out of his senses, or is melancholy
mad.” But Origen here quotes Plato in connection with the reality
of the Resurrection body of Christ: Gregory refers to ghosts only, with
regard to the φιλοσώματοι, whose whole condition after death he represents very much
in Plato’s words. See Phædo, p. 81 B.