230
Book XI.
§1. The eleventh book shows that the title of “Good” is due, not to the Father alone, as
Eunomius, the imitator of Manichæus and Bardesanes, alleges, but to the Son also, Who
formed man in goodness and loving-kindness, and reformed him by His Cross and Death.
Let us now go on to the next stage in his argument:—“….the Only-begotten Himself
ascribing to the Father the title due of right to Him alone. For He Who has taught us that
the appellation ‘good’ belongs to Him alone Who is the cause of His own971 goodness and
of all goodness, and is so at all times, and Who refers to Him all good that has ever come
into being, would be slow to appropriate to Himself the authority over all things that have
come into being, and the title of ‘the Existent.’” Well, so long as he concealed his blasphemy
under some kind of veil, and strove to entangle his deluded hearers unawares in the mazes
of his dialectic, I thought it necessary to watch his unfair and clandestine dealings, and as
far as possible to lay bare in my argument the lurking mischief. But now that he has stripped
his falsehood of every mask that could disguise it, and publishes his profanity aloud in cat-
egorical terms, I think it superfluous to undergo useless labour in bringing logical modes
of confutation to bear upon those who make no secret of their impiety. For what further
means could we discover to demonstrate their malignity so efficacious as that which they
themselves show us in their writings ready to our hand? He says that the Father alone is
worthy of the title of “good,” that to Him alone such a name is due, on the plea that even
the Son Himself agrees that goodness belongs to Him alone. Our accuser has pleaded our
cause for us: for perhaps in my former statements I was thought by my readers to show a
certain wanton insolence when I endeavoured to demonstrate that the fighters against Christ
made Him out to be alien from the goodness of the Father. But I think it has now been
proved by the confession of our opponents that in bringing such a charge against them we
were not acting unfairly. For he who says that the title of “good” belongs of right to the
Father only, and that such an address befits Him alone, publishes abroad, by thus disclosing
his real meaning, the villainy which he had previously wrapped up in disguise. He says that
the title of “good” befits the Father only. Does he mean the title with the signification which
belongs to the expression, or the title detached from its proper meaning? If on the one side
he merely ascribes to the Father the title of “good” in a special sense, he is to be pitied for
his irrationality in allowing to the Father merely the sound of an empty name. But if he
thinks that the conception expressed by the term “good” belongs to God the Father only,
he is to be abominated for his impiety, reviving as he does the plague of the Manichæan
heresy in his own opinions. For as health and disease, even so goodness and badness exist
on terms of mutual destruction, so that the absence of the one is the presence of the other.
971 That is, of the Son’s goodness: for S. Gregory’s comment on the awkward use of the pronoun σφετέρας,
see p. 233, inf.
Book XIThe eleventh book shows that the title of “Good” is due, not to the Father alone, as Eunomius, the imitator of Manichæus and Bardesanes, alleges, but to the Son also, Who formed man in goodness and loving-kindness, and reformed him by His Cross and Death.
439
Book XI