Testimonia

Publiek archief van verzamelde en verwerkte bronrecords.
Overzicht / tekstblob

Tekstblob

sha256: 9587d8f6791e75e1c56e0c00dab260cdee8b284bd6f59cfc74c0b2d79310ba9a · 2,208 tekens

11.  Its title to being (as it undoubtedly is) the Second of the Ecumenical Synods rests upon its Creed having found a reception in the whole world.  And now—mirabile dictu—an English scholar comes forward, ready to defend the proposition that the First Council of Constantinople never set forth any creed at all! F. J. A. Hort, Two Dissertations.  I. On μονογένης Θέος in Scripture and tradition, II. On the Constantinopolitan Creed and other Eastern Creeds of the 4th Century.  It should be added that Dr. Hort acknowledges that, “we may well believe that they [i.e. the 150 fathers of Constantinople] had expressed approval” of the creed ordinarily attributed to them (p. 115).  The whole dissertation is a fine example of what Dr. Salmon so well called Dr. Hort’s “perfervidum ingenium as an advocate,” and of his “exaggeration of judgment.”  (Salmon.  Criticism of the Text of the New Testament, p. 12, also see p. 34.)  Swainson, in his The Nicene and Apostles’ Creeds, has all the material points found in Hort’s Dissertation.  Harnack goes much further.  He is of opinion that the Creed of Constantinople (as we call it), the Creed which has been the symbol of orthodoxy for fifteen hundred years, is really a Semi-Arian, anti-Nicene, and quasi Macedonian confession!  The first contention he supports, not without a show of plausibility, by the fact that it omits the words (which were really most crucial) “that is to say of the substance of the Father.”  In support of the second opinion he writes as follows:  “The words [with regard to the Holy Ghost] are in entire harmony with the form which the doctrine of the Holy Spirit had in the sixties.  A Pneumatochian could have subscribed this formula at a pinch; and just because of this it is certain that the Council of 381 did not accept this creed.”  Some scholars arrive at “certainty” more easily than others, even Harnack himself only attains this “certainty” in the foot-note!  The reader will remark that what Harnack is “certain ”of in the foot-note is that the Council “did not accept” this creed, not that it “did not frame” it, which is entirely a different question.  (Adolf Harnack, History of Dogma, [Eng. Trans.], Vol. iv., p. 99.)

Alle records · Zoek op deze hash