c. Inconsistencies with Athanasius. It is
the most serious objection to the Athanasian authorship of the
Vita that Athanasius (with the exception of the
‘antilegomenon’ Hist. Ar. 14) nowhere else mentions
Antony by name. Especially in the letter to Dracontius, who at first
refused the Episcopate in the supposed interests of his soul, we might,
it is argued, have expected a reference to the deep reverence of Antony
(§67) for even the lowest clergy (the persons enumerated,
Letter 49, §7, are bishops who had previously been
monks, and have nothing to do with this question). That is true. We
might have expected it. But as a matter of fact Athanasius uses
another argument instead (see Letter 49, §3, note
8a). It does not follow that he did not know of the
Antony of the Vita. But although the letter in question has been
pressed unduly, the general objection, as an argumentum ex
silentio on a rather large scale, remains It is
fortified by the ‘silence of Eusebius’ (1) as to monks in
general (but yet see H. E. II. 17, vol. i., p. 116, note in this
series); (2) as to the part played by Antony at Alexandria during the
persecution (H. E. VII. 32, VIII. 13, IX. 6); (3) as to
Constantine’s letter to Antony (§81).. Some
more detailed points must now be considered.