As to the
See of Prima Justiniana, the Metropolitan jurisdiction assigned to it
by the Emperor Justinian, and the vicariate jurisdiction that had been
transferred to it from Thessalonica by the popes, see note on
Lib. II., Ep. 22. The circumstances referred to in
this and the following letter are interesting as shewing, among other
things, the relations of the See of Rome to the Church in Illyricum,
and the action of the Emperors with regard to it. They may be
epitomized as follows. Thebæ Phthioticæ was a See in
the province of Thessalia, of which Larissa was the Metropolis.
But, as appears from what Gregory says in Epistle VII., Thebæ had
been for some reason exempted from the metropolitan jurisdiction of the
bishop of Larissa by pope Pelagius II. John and Cosmas, two
deposed deacons of the Church of Thebæ, had sent a representation
to the Emperor, accusing their bishop, Adrian, of defalcations in money
matters, and also of certain misdemeanours; the latter being that he
had retained in office one of his deacons, Stephen, whose shameful life
was notorious, and that he had ordered baptism to be refused to certain
infants, who had consequently died unbaptized. The Emperor
(Mauricius) referred the matter to John, bishop of Larissa, as
Metropolitan of Thessalia, who, notwithstanding the exemption of
Thebæ from his jurisdiction by pope Pelagius II., took it up, and
decided against Adrian, at any rate with respect to his alleged
pecuniary defalcations. Adrian appealed against this decision to
the Emperor, who thereupon deputed certain persons (not bishops) to
enquire and report, and, on receiving their report, exempted Adrian
from further proceedings, sending an order to that effect to the Bishop
of Corinth, who was Metropolitan of the adjoining province of
Achaia. Meanwhile John of Larissa had imprisoned Adrian, and
elicited from him (under compulsion, it was said) an ambiguous
confession of his guilt, and also obtained from the Emperor a second
order committing the reinvestigation and final adjudication of the case
to John, bishop of Prima Justiniana, who confirmed the sentence of John
of Larissa, and deposed Adrian from his See. Adrian now at last
appealed to the pope, and went himself to Rome to seek aid from
Gregory, who took up the case at once and strenuously declared the past
proceedings unfair, uncanonical, and void, ordered the immediate
restoration of Adrian to his See, excommunicated John of Prima
Justiniana, and forbade John of Larissa, under pain of excommunication,
to assume hereafter any metropolitan jurisdiction over the church of
Thebæ. Now it is plain that, till Adrian’s final
appeal, no recourse was had by any of the parties concerned to the See
of Rome, and that the Emperor, who alone was at first appealed to, took
the matter up on his own authority without reference to Rome: nor
was it till he had failed of redress from Constantinople that Adrian
himself appealed to Gregory. But it is equally evident that
Gregory, when appealed to, asserted his own plenary jurisdiction as
matter of course and without hesitation: nor is there any
evidence to shew that his assertion of authority was resisted either by
the Illyrican prelates or the Emperor. It was probably a case in
which the Emperor himself took little interest; and he might be glad
that the pope should take it out of his hands and settle it. It
was otherwise, however, in a subsequent case (though occurring not in
Eastern, but in Western Illyricum), in which Gregory was at issue with
the Emperor with respect to the appointment of a bishop to the See of
Salona, as will be seen hereafter. See III. 47, note
2.