8. In the third book the following faulty statements are
contained. “If we once admit that, when one vessel is made to
honour and another to dishonour, 2 Tim. ii. 20. this is
due to antecedent causes; why may we not revert to the mystery of the
soul and allow that it is loved in one and hated in another because of
its past actions, before in Jacob it becomes a supplanter and before in
Esau it is supplanted?” Mal. i. 2, 3. And again:
“the fact that souls are made some to honour and some to
dishonour is to be explained by their previous history.” And in
the same place: “on this hypothesis of mine a vessel made to
honour which fails to fulfil its object will in another world become a
vessel made to dishonour; and contrariwise a vessel which has from a
previous fault been condemned to dishonour will, if it accepts
correction in this present life, become in the new creation a vessel
‘sanctified and meet for the Master’s use and prepared unto
every good work.’” 2 Tim. ii. 21. And he
immediately goes on to say: “I believe that men who begin with
small faults may become so hardened in wickedness that, if they do not
repent and turn to better things, they must become inhuman energies; i.e.
demons. and contrariwise that hostile and
demonic beings may in course of time so far heal their wounds and check
the current of their former sins that they may attain to the abode of
the perfect. As I have often said, in those countless and unceasing
worlds in which the soul lives and has its being some grow worse and
worse until they reach the lowest depths of degradation; while others
in those lowest depths grow better and better until they reach the
perfection of virtue.” Thus he tries to shew that men, or rather
their souls, may become demons; and that demons in turn may be restored
to the rank of angels. In the same book he writes: “this too must
be considered; why the human soul is diversely acted upon now by
influences of one kind and now by influences of another.” And he
surmises that this is due to conduct which has preceded birth. It is
for this, he argues, that John leaps in his mother’s womb when at
Mary’s salutation Elizabeth declares herself unworthy of her
notice. Luke i. 41. And he immediately subjoins:
“on the other hand infants that are hardly weaned are possessed
with evil spirits and become diviners and soothsayers; Cf. Acts xvi. 16, A.V. margin. indeed, some are indwelt from their
earliest years with the spirit of a python. Now as they have done
nothing to bring upon themselves these visitations, one who holds that
nothing happens without God’s permission, and that all things are
governed by His justice, cannot suppose that God’s providence has
abandoned them without good reason.”