which simplicity does not belong is manifestly various and composite. How then can the
same Person be at once non-existent and composite in essence? For one of two alternatives
they must choose: if they predicate of Him non-existence they cannot speak of Him as
composite, or if they affirm Him to be composite they cannot rob Him of existence. But
that their blasphemy may assume many and varied shapes, it jumps at every godless notion
when it wishes to contrast Him with the existent, affirming that, strictly speaking, He does
not exist, and in His relation to the uncompounded Nature denying Him the attribute of
simplicity:—“not existing, not existing simply, not existing in the strict sense.” Who among
those who have transgressed the word and forsworn the Faith was ever so lavish in utterances
denying the Lord? He has stood up in rivalry with the divine proclamation of John. For as
often as the latter has attested “was” of the Word, so often does he apply to Him Who is an
opposing “was not.” And he contends against the holy lips of our father Basil, bringing
against him the charge that he “neglects these distinctions,” when he says that He Who is
in the Father, and in the beginning, and in the bosom of the Father, exists, holding the view
that the addition of “in the beginning,” and “in the bosom of the Father,” bars the real exist-
ence of Him Who is. Vain learning! What things the teachers of deceit teach! what strange
doctrines they introduce to their hearers! they instruct them that that which is in something
else does not exist! So, Eunomius, since your heart and brain are within you, neither of
them, according to your distinction, exists. For if the Only-begotten God does not, strictly
speaking, exist, for this reason, that He is in the bosom of the Father, then everything that
is in something else is thereby excluded from existence. But certainly your heart exists in
you, and not independently; therefore, according to your view, you must either say that it
does not exist at all, or that it does not exist in the strict sense. However, the ignorance and
profanity of his language are so gross and so glaring, as to be obvious even before our argu-
ment, at all events to all persons of sense: but that his folly as well as his impiety may be
more manifest, we will add thus much to what has gone before. If one may only say that
that in the strict sense exists, of which the word of Scripture attests the existence detached
from all relation to anything else, why do they, like those who carry water, perish with thirst
when they have it in their power to drink? Even this man, though he had at hand the antidote
to his blasphemy against the Son, closed his eyes and ran past it as though fearing to be
saved, and charges Basil with unfairness for having suppressed the qualifying words, and
for only quoting the “was” by itself, in reference to the Only-Begotten. And yet it was quite
in his power to see what Basil saw and what every one who has eyes sees. And herein the
sublime John seems to me to have been prophetically moved, that the mouths of those
fighters against Christ might be stopped, who on the ground of these additions deny the
existence, in the strict sense, of the Christ, saying simply and without qualification “The
Word was God,” and was Life, and was Light953, not merely speaking of Him as being in
953 Cf. S. John i. 1, 4
432
After this he shows that the Son, who truly is, and is in the bosom of the…