The tone of high compliment—nay, of
adulation—which marks these letters has been justly regarded as a
blot, much to be regretted, on the lustre of Gregory’s
character. There
is indeed no
reason to conclude that he knew so far of the peculiar blackness of the
usurper’s character, as depicted by contemporary historians, and
evinced by his disastrous and sanguinary reign. And, seeing
that it appears from Epistle 38 that he had had no apocrisiarius
resident at Constantinople towards the end of the reign of Mauricius,
it may be that he had not been fully informed of the cruelties that
accompanied the accession of Phocas to the imperial throne;—how,
for instance, five sons of the former emperor had been murdered in
succession before their father’s eyes, and then the emperor
himself, their bodies being thrown into the Tiber, and their heads
exposed in Constantinople till putrefaction began. But, however
this might be, Gregory’s high-flown compliments addressed to the
new potentates, and his excessive exultation on their accession, cannot
but strike one as unseemly as well as premature. Nor is it
pleasant to observe his exultant way of speaking of the fall of the
late emperor, whose sad fate called for so much sympathy, and to whom
he had himself once written in such terms as these:— “Since
a sincere rectitude of faith shines in you, most Christian of princes,
like a light sent from heaven, and since it is known to all that your
Serenity embraces with all your heart the pure profession which wins
the favour of God” (VI. 16). Again, “Amidst the cares
of warfare, and innumerable anxieties which you sustain in your
unwearied zeal for the government of the Christian republic, it is a
great cause of joy to me, along with the whole world, that your Piety
ever keeps guard over the faith whereby the empire of our lords is
resplendent” (VI. 65). Again, about him, only some two
years before his death, in a letter to the patriarch of Jerusalem,
“Thanks should be given without cease to Almighty God, and prayer
ever made for the life of our most pious and Christian lord the
Emperor, and for his most tranquil spouse, and his most gentle
offspring, in whose times the mouths of heretics are silent,
&c.” (XI. 46). Doubtless Maurice’s inefficiency
with regard to the Lombards had been exceedingly provoking, and perhaps
still more so to Gregory himself, his support of the Patriarch of
Constantinople in his assumption of the offensive title. And
perhaps the gout from which Gregory appears to have been suffering
intensely at the time may partly account for his having given vent as
he did to feelings of irritation long suppressed. Then, with
regard to his adulation of the new potentates, some excuse may be found
in prevalent usage, or his own habitual deference to the powers that
be, or his policy (apparent also in his letters to Brunehild) of
enlisting their support by flattering addresses to the cause of
religion and the Church. But still a painful impression remains;
though, on the other hand, it may be observed with truth that few great
historical characters of whom so much is known are stained by so few
disfiguring blots as that of Gregory. It may be presumed that a
prominent motive of his paying court to the rising suns was his hope of
getting their support against the patriarch. He does not indeed
refer distinctly to the title; but in his letter to Leontia (whom,
rather than the emperor, with characteristic address, he warns about
her spiritual prospects being dependent on the favour of St. Peter) we
can hardly mistake the covert allusion. If so, his policy was not
fruitless. For, though there is no sufficient foundation for the
statement of Baronius, that Phocas formally conferred on pope Boniface
III. the title of “Universal Bishop” which had been assumed
by the patriarch, there seems to be no good reason for doubting that
the new emperor took the pope’s part against Cyriacus, who had
offended him by his protection of Constantina and her daughters, and
that, when Boniface, who had been Gregory’s apocrisiarius at
Constantinople, himself became pope, an imperial edict of some kind was
issued in favour of the claims of Rome. The words of Anastasius,
the biographer of the popes towards the end of the ninth century, with
reference to it are these: “He (i.e. Boniface) obtained
from the emperor Phocas that the Apostolic See of St. Peter, that is,
the Roman Church, should be the head of all Churches, because the
Church of Constantinople wrote itself the first of all
Churches.” The authority, however, of Anastasius, who lived
in a time of hierarchical forgeries, cannot be relied on without
reserve.