places, especially chronological errors—for instance, regarding the death of Constantine
the Great—we cannot unconditionally accept its statement as to the date 344, but can only
do so when it corresponds with other dates concerning that time.
Let us, at all events, assume that Athanasius came to Rome about Easter, 340. As is
known, he was there for three whole years, and in the beginning of the fourth year was
summoned to the Emperor Constans at Milan. This points to the summer of 343. From
thence he went through Gaul to Sardica, and thus it is quite possible that that Synod might
have begun in the autumn of 343. It probably lasted, however, until the spring; for when
the two envoys, Euphrates of Cologne, and Vincent of Capua, who were sent by the Synod
414
to the Emperor Constans, arrived in Antioch, it was already Easter 344. Stephen, the bishop
of the latter city, treated them in a truly diabolical manner; but his wickedness soon became
notorious, and a synod was established, which deposed him after Easter 344. Its members
were Eusebians, who therefore appointed Leontius Castratus as Stephen’s successor, and it
is indeed no other than this assembly which Athanasius has in mind, when he says it took
place three years after the Synod in Encæniis, and drew up a very explicit Eusebian confession
of faith, the μακρόστιχος.
The disgraceful behaviour of Bishop Stephen of Antioch for some time inclined the
Emperor to place less confidence in the Arian party, and to allow Athanasius’s exiled clergy
to return home in the summer of 344. Ten months later, the pseudo-bishop, Gregory of
Alexandria, died (in June, 345), and Constantius did not permit any fresh appointment to
the see of Alexandria, but recalled St. Athanasius by three letters, and waited for him more
than a year. Thus the see of Alexandria remained unoccupied for more than a year, until
the last six months of 346. At length, in October, 346, Athanasius returned to his bishopric.
We see then that by accepting the distinct statements of the Paschal Letters of St. Ath-
anasius and the preface, we obtain a satisfactory chronological system in which the separate
details cohere well together, and which thus recommends itself. One great objection which
we formerly raised ourselves against the date 344 can now be solved. It is certainly true that
in 353 or 354 Pope Librius wrote thus: “Eight years ago the Eusebian deputies, Eudoxius
and Martyrius (who came to the West with the formula μακρόστικος), refused to anathem-
atize the Arian doctrine at Milan.” But the Synod of Milan here alluded to, and placed about
the year 345, was not, as we before erroneously supposed, held before the Synod of Sardica,
but after it. We are somewhat less fortunate as regards another difficulty. The Eusebians
assembled at Philippopolis (the pseudo-synod of Sardica) say, in their synodal letter:
“Bishop Asclepas of Gaza was deposed from his bishopric seventeen years ago.” This depos-
ition occurred at an Antiochian synod. If we identified this synod with the well-known one
of 330, by which Eustathius of Antioch also was overthrown, we should, reckoning the
seventeen years, have the year 346 or 347, in which to place the writing of the Synodal Letter
of Philippopolis, and therefore the Synod of Sardica. There are, however, two ways of
757
Introduction on the Date of the Council.