Now I broach these ridiculously
childish suggestions as to children sitting in the market-place and
playing Luke vii. 32.; for when one looks into the grovelling
earthliness of their heretical teaching it is impossible to help
falling into a sort of sportive childishness. It would be right,
however, to add this to what we have said, viz., that, as the idea of
eternity is completed only by means of both (as we have already
argued), by the negation of a beginning and also by that of an end, if
they confine God’s being to the one, their definition of this
being will be manifestly imperfect and curtailed by half; it is thought
of only by the absence of beginning, and does not contain the absence
of end within itself as an essential element. But if they do combine
both negations, and so complete their definition of the being of God,
observe, again, the absurdity that is at once apparent in this view; it
will be found, after all their efforts, to be at variance not only with
the Only-begotten, but with itself. The case is clear and does not
require much dwelling upon. The idea of a beginning and the idea of an
end are opposed each to each; the meanings of each differ as widely as
the other diametric oppositions κατὰ
διάμετρον
ἀλλήλοις
ἀντικειμένων, i.e. Contradictories in Logic., where there is no
half-way proposition below As in A
or E, both of which have the Particular below them (I or O) as a
half-way to the contrary Universal. Thus—
A I E
All men are mortal. Some men are mortal. No men are mortal.
E O A
No men are mortal. Some men
are not mortal. All men are mortal.
But between A and O, E and
I, there is no half-way.. If any one is asked
to define ‘beginning,’ he will not give a definition the
same as that of end; but will carry his definition of it to the
opposite extremity. Therefore also the two contraries Beginning (Contraries) Beginningless.
Endless (Contraries)
Ending. of these will be separated
from each other by the same distance of opposition; and that which is
without beginning, being contrary to that which is to be seen by a
beginning, will be a very different thing from that which is endless,
or the negation of end. If, then, they import both these attributes
into the being of God, I mean the negations of end and of beginning,
they will exhibit this Deity of theirs as a combination of two
contradictory and discordant things, because the contrary ideas
to beginning and end reproduce on their side also the
contradiction existing between beginning and end. Contraries of
contradictories are themselves contradictory of each other. In fact, it
is always a true axiom, that two things which are naturally opposed to
two things mutually opposite are themselves opposed to each other; as
we may see by example. Water is opposed to fire; therefore also the
forces destructive of these are opposed to each other; if moistness is
apt to extinguish fire, and dryness is apt to destroy water, the
opposition of fire to water is continued in those qualities themselves
which are contrary to them; so that dryness is plainly opposed to
moistness. Thus, when beginning and end have to be placed
(diametrically) opposite each other ὑπεναντίως
διακειμένων. The same term has been used to express the opposition
between Ungenerate and Generated: so that it means both Oppositions,
i.e. Contraries and Contradictories., the terms
contrary to these also contradict each other in their meaning, I mean,
the negations of end and of beginning. Well, then, if they determine
that one only of these negations is indicative of the being (to repeat
my former assertion), they will bear evidence to half only of
God’s existence, confining it to the absence of beginning, and
refusing to extend it to the absence of end; whereas, if they import
both into their definition of it, they will actually exhibit it so as a
combination of contradictions in the way that has been said; for these
two negations of beginning and of end, by virtue of the contradiction
existing between beginning and end, will part it asunder. So their
Deity will be found to be a sort of patchwork compound, a conglomerate
of contradictions.