264 THE SEVEN BOOKS OF [Book v.
thought or believed more impious than that the rape of
Proserpine speaks of seeds buried in the earth, or anything
else (for in like manner it is of no importance), and that it
speaks of the pursuit of agriculture to’ the dishonour of
father Dis? Is it not a thousand times more desirable to
become mute and speechless, and to lose that flow of words
and noisy and? unseemly loquacity, than to call the basest
things by the names of the gods; nay, more, to signify
commonplace things by the base actions of the gods ?
41. It was once usual, in speaking allegorically, to conceal
under perfectly decent ideas, and clothe? with the respect-
ability of decency, what was base and horrible to speak of
openly ; but now venerable things are at your instance
vilely spoken of, and what is quite pure * is related? in filthy
language, so that that which vice? formerly concealed from
shame, is now meanly and basely spoken of, the mode of speech
which was fitting’ being changed. In speaking of Mars
and Venus as having been taken in adultery by Vulcan’s art,
we speak of lust, says [my opponent], and anger, as restrained
by the force and purpose of reason. What, then, hindered,
what prevented you from expressing each thing by the words
and terms proper to it? nay, more, what necessity was there,
when you had resolved? to declare something or other, by
means of treatises and writings, to resolve that that should
not be the meaning to which you point, and in one narrative
to take up at the same time opposite positions—the eagerness
of one wishing to teach, the niggardliness of one reluctant to
make public ?? Was there no risk in speaking of the gods
2 Lit., ** with.” 2 Lit., ** din of.”
3 Passive. 1 Lit., ** strong in chastity.”
5 The ms., first three edd., Elm., and Oehler read commorantur—
‘‘lingers,” ie. continues to be spoken of;” the other edd. receive
commemorantur, as above, from the errata in the 1st ed.
6 The s., first four edd., and Oehler read gravitas—seriousness ; cor-
rected pr. as above, in all edd. after Stewechius.
7 So, perhaps, the unintelligible Ms. dignorum should be emendcd
digna rerum.
8 So all edd. since Stewechius, adding s to the ws. voluisse.
? i.e. the mere fact that the stories were published, showed a wish to