AGAINST JOV1NIANUS.— BOOK I.
359
a person twice married ' cannot be enrolled in the ranks of the clergy, and so the Apostle
tells Timothy,2 " Let none be enrolled as a widow under threescore years old, having
been the wife of one man." The whole command concerns those widows who are
supported on the alms of the Church. The
age is therefore limited, so that those only
may receive the food of the poor who can no
longer work. And at the same time, consider
that she who has had two husbands, even
though she be a widow, decrepit, and in want,
is not a worthy recipient of the Church's funds. But if she be deprived of the bread
of charity, how much more is she deprived of
that bread which cometh down from heaven,
and of which if a man eat unworthily, he shall
be guilty of outrage offered to the body and the blood of Christ ?
15. The passages, however, which I have
adduced in support of my position and in
which it is permitted to widows, if they so
desire, to marry again, are interpreted by
some concerning those widows who had lost
their husbands and were found in that condi-
tion when they became Christians. For, sup-
posing a person baptized and her husband
dead, it would not be consistent if the Apostle
were to bid her marry another, when he en-
joins even those who have wives to be as
though they had them not. And this is why
the number of wives which a man may take
is not defined, because when Christian baptism
has been received, even though a third or a
fourth wife has been taken, she is reckoned as
the first. Otherwise, if, after baptism and after
the death of a first husband, a second is taken,
why should not a sixth after the death of the
second, third, fourth, and fifth, and so on ?
l-'or it is possible, that through some strange misfortune, or by the judgement of God cutting
short repeated marriages, a young woman may
have several husbands, while an old woman
may be left a widow by her first husband in
extreme age. The first Adam was married once : the second was unmarried. Let the
supporters of second marriages shew us as
their leader a third Adam who was twice mar-
ried. But granted that Paul allowed second
marriages : upon the same grounds it follows
that he allows even third and fourth marriages,
or a woman may marry as often as her husband
dies. The Apostle was forced to choose many
things which he did not like. He circumcised
Timothy, and shaved his own head, practised
1 See i Tim. iii. 12. Most ancient writers interpreted S. Paul's is referring to second marriages after loss of first wife,
however happening. And certain Councils decided in the same
sense, e. g. Neocaesarca lA.IX 314). Ellicott's Pastoral Ep., fifth ed.. p. 41.
8 i Tim. v. 9. Other authorities, however, suppose the words to rtfer to an order of widows, and pertinently ask, would the Church thus limit her alms.
going barefoot, let his hair grow long, and cut it
at Cenchrea. And he had certainly chastised
the Galatians, and blamed Peter because for
the sake of Jewish observances he separated himself from the Gentiles. As then in other
points connected with the discipline of the
Church he was a Jew to Jews, a Gentile to
Gentiles, and was made all things to all men,
that he might gain all : so too he allowed sec-
ond marriages to incontinent persons, and did
not limit the number of marriages, in order that
women, although they saw themselves per- mitted to take a second husband, in the same
way as a third or a fourth was allowed, might
blush to take a second, lest they should be com-
pared to those who were three or four times
married. If more than one husband be allowed,
it makes no difference whether he be a second
or a third, because there is no longer a ques-
tion of single marriage. ' " All things are law-
ful, but not all things are expedient." I do not condemn second, nor third, nor, pardon
the expression, eighth marriages : I will go
still further and say that I welcome even
a penitent whoremonger. Things that are
equally lawful must be weighed in an even balance.
1 6. But he takes us to the Old Testament,
and beginning with Adam goes on to Zacharias and Elizabeth. He next confronts us with
Peter and the rest of the Apostles. We are
therefore bound to traverse the same course
of argument and show that chastity was al-
ways preferred to the condition of marriage.
And as regards Adam and Eve we must main- tain that before the fall they were virgins in
Paradise : but after they sinned, and were
cast out of Paradise, they were immediately
married. Then we have the passage,2 " For this cause shall a man leave his father and
mother, and shall cleave to his wife, and the
twain shall become one flesh," in explanation
of which the Apostle straightway adds,3 " This mystery is great, but I speak in regard of
Christ, and of the Church." Christ in the flesh is a virgin, in the spirit he is once mar- ried. For he has one Church, concerning
which the same Apostle says,4 " Husbands, love your wives, even as Christ also loved the
Church." If Christ loves the Church holily, chastely, and without spot, let husbands also
love their wives in chastity. And let every-
one know how to possess his vessel in sanc- tification and honour, not in the lust of
concupiscence, as the Gentiles who know not
God : '" " For God called us not for unclean- ness, but in sanctification : seeing that ye have
put off the old man with his doings, and have
1 i Cor. vi. 12.
3 Eph. v. 32.
6 i Thess. iv. 7.
2 Eph. v. 31 : Gen. ii.
4 Eph. v. 25 : Col. iii. 9-11.