Chapter LI.
In the next place, he expresses his approval of those who “hope that eternal life shall be
enjoyed with God by the soul or mind, or, as it is variously called, the spiritual nature, the
reasonable soul, intelligent, holy, and blessed;” and he allows the soundness of the doctrine,
“that those who had a good life shall be happy, and the unrighteous shall suffer eternal
punishments.” And yet I wonder at what follows, more than at anything that Celsus has
ever said; for he adds, “And from this doctrine let not them or any one ever swerve.” For
certainly in writing against Christians, the very essence of whose faith is God, and the
promises made by Christ to the righteous, and His warnings of punishment awaiting the
wicked, he must see that, if a Christian were brought to renounce Christianity by his argu-
ments against it, it is beyond doubt that, along with his Christian faith, he would cast off
the very doctrine from which he says that no Christian and no man should ever swerve.
But I think Celsus has been far surpassed in consideration for his fellow-men by Chrysippus
in his treatise, On the Subjugation of the Passions. For when he sought to apply remedies
to the affections and passions which oppress and distract the human spirit, after employing
such arguments as seemed to himself to be strong, he did not shrink from using in the second
and third place others which he did not himself approve of. “For,” says he, “if it were held
by any one that there are three kinds of good, we must seek to regulate the passions in ac-
cordance with that supposition; and we must not too curiously inquire into the opinions
held by a person at the time that he is under the influence of passion, lest, if we delay too
long for the purpose of overthrowing the opinions by which the mind is possessed, the op-
portunity for curing the passion may pass away.” And he adds, “Thus, supposing that
pleasure were the highest good, or that he was of that opinion whose mind was under the
dominion of passion, we should not the less give him help, and show that, even on the
principle that pleasure is the highest and final good of man, all passion is disallowed.” And
Celsus, in like manner, after having embraced the doctrine, “that the righteous shall be
blessed, and the wicked shall suffer eternal punishments,” should have followed out his
659
subject; and, after having advanced what seemed to him the chief argu ment, he should have
proceeded to prove and enforce by further reasons the truth that the unjust shall surely
suffer eternal punishment, and those who lead a good life shall be blessed.
Chapter LI
1542
Chapter LI