No collection appeared from this date until the “Collectio Regia,” a magnificent series
of thirty-seven volumes folio, at the royal press at Paris in 1644. But while it was superb in
get up, it left much to be desired when looked at critically, for many faults of the Roman
edition already pointed out by Sirmond were not corrected.
And now we have reached the time when the first really great Concilia appeared, which
while only filling seventeen volumes in folio was yet far more complete —Hefele says twenty-
five per cent. more complete—than the great Collectio Regia just described. This edition
was the work of Philip Labbe (Labbeus in Latin), S. J., and was completed after his death in
1667, by Father Gabriel Cossart of the same Society—“Almost all the French savants quote
from this edition of Labbe’s with Baluze’s supplement,”15 and I have followed their lead,
xx
availing myself of the corrections made by later editors. The title of the edition used in this
work is: “Sacrasancta Concilia ad Regiam Editionem exacta. Studio Philip. Labbei et Gabr.
Cossartii, Soc. Jesu Presbyterorum. Lutetiæ Parisiorum. MDCLXXI. Cum Privilegio Regis
Christianissimi.”
Anything more perfect than these precious volumes it would be hard to conceive of,
and while of course they contain the errors of chronology et cetera of their age, yet their
general accuracy and marvellous completeness leave them even to-day as the greatest of the
great, although the later edition of Hardouin is more often used by English and American
scholars, and is the one quoted by Pope Benedict XIV. in his famous work De Synodo
Diæcesana. Hardouin’s edition did certainly correct many of the faults of Labbe and Cossart,
yet had itself many faults and defects which are pointed out by Salmon16 in a long list, al-
though he fully acknowledges the value of Hardouin’s improvements and additions. Perhaps,
not unnaturally, as a Professor at the Sorbonne, he preferred Labbe and Cossart. It may not
be amiss to add that Hardouin was very anti-Gallican and ultramontane.
The Dominican Archbishop of Lucca, Mansi, in 1759, put out his “Concilia” in thirty-
one volumes folio at Florence, styled on the title-page “the most ample” edition ever printed,
and claiming to contain all the old and much new matter. It was never finished, only
reaching to the XVth century, has no indices, and (says Hefele) “is very inferior to Hardouin
in accuracy. The order of the subjects in the later volumes is sometimes not sufficiently
methodical, and is at variance with the chronology.”17
I shall now present the reader with some bibliographical notes which I extract verbatim
from Hefele (Hefele, History of the Councils, Vol. I., p. 74).
Among the numerous works on the history of the councils, the most useful to consult
are:
15 Hefele, Hist. Councils, vol. I, p. 69.
16 Salmon, l. c., pp. 315–331, 786–831.
17 Hefele, Hist. Councils, vol. I, p. 72.
17
Bibliographical Introduction.