1. I have at last received from Africa your joint letter
and no longer regret the effrontery which led me, in spite of your
silence to ply you both with so many missives. I hoped, indeed, by so
doing to gain a reply and to learn of your welfare not indirectly from
others but directly from yourselves. I well remember your little
problem about the nature of the soul; although I ought not to call it
little, seeing that it is one of the greatest with which the church has
to deal. You ask whether it has fallen from heaven, as Pythagoras, all
Platonists, and Origen suppose; or whether it is part of God’s
essence as the Stoics, Manes, and the Spanish Priscillianists hint.
Whether souls created long since are kept in God’s storehouse as
some ecclesiastical writers The allusion is
probably to Clement of Alexandria. foolishly
imagine; or whether they are formed by God and introduced into bodies
day by day according to that saying in the Gospel: “my Father
worketh hitherto and I work;” John v. 17. or whether,
lastly, they are transmitted by propagation. This is the view of
Tertullian, Apollinaris, and most western writers who hold that soul is
derived from soul as body is from body and that the conditions of life
are the same for men and brutes. I have given my opinion on the matter
in my reply to the treatise which Rufinus presented to Anastasius,
bishop of Rome, of holy memory. He strives in this by an evasive and
crafty but sufficiently foolish confession to play with the simplicity
of his hearers, but only succeeds in playing with his own faith or
rather want of it. My book, Against
Rufinus, ii. §§ 8–10; iii. §30; in neither
place, however, does Jerome clearly state his own view. which has been
published a good while, contains an answer to the calumnies which in
his various writings Rufinus has directed against me. Your reverend
father Oceanus See Letter LXIX,
introduction. It is doubtful whether Oceanus was in holy orders
although the title ‘father’ seems to imply it. has, I think, a
copy of it. But if you cannot procure it your bishop Augustine is both
learned and holy. He will teach you by word of mouth and will give you
his opinion, or rather mine, in his own words.