Thirdly, the term ἀγένητος demands
attention. It is impossible to give its exact force in idiomatic
English: the rendering ‘Ingenerate’ adopted by Newman is
perhaps the most unfortunate one imaginable. ‘Uncreated,’ a
possible substitute, is also open to objection, firstly, as not
distinguishing the word from the derivatives of κτίζειν,
ποιεῖν,
δημιουργεῖν,
secondly, as giving it a passive sense, which does not inherently
attach to it. For lack of a better word, ‘Unoriginate’ may
perhaps be adopted. ‘That which has not (or cannot) come to
be,’ ‘that which is not the result of a
process,’—is what the word strictly
signifies’—‘das Ungewordene.’ It was
therefore strictly applicable to the Son as well as to the Father. But
throughout the earlier stages of the Arian controversy the question was
embarrassed by the homophones γέννητος and ἀγέννητος, generate
or begotten, and unbegotten. The confusion of thought due to the
resemblance of sound is reflected in the confusion of readings in the
mss. Athanasius himself (Orat. i. 56)
perceives the distinctive sense of ἀγέννητος. In
the present tract and in Orat. i. 30, he has ἀγένητος only in view,
the idea of begetting being absent. Here (and cf. de Syn. 46,
note 5) he is denying that the Father is alone ἀγένητος, uncreated or
without a ‘becoming.’ Accordingly although the word γεννήθεντα
was consecrated and safeguarded in the Creed of Nicæa (Begotten
not made), and although the distinctness of the derivatives of the two
verbs was felt by Athanasius, and pointed out by others (Epiph.
Hær. 64, 8), the use of either group of words was avoided
by Catholics as dangerous. A clear distinction of the words and of
their respective applicability is made by John Damascene Fid.
Orth. I. viii. (see Lightfoot, Ignat. vol. 2, excursus on
Eph. §7, Thilo, ubi supra, Introd. p. 14, and Harnack,
Dg. 2, p. 193 note).