1852-1] MAZZINI ON CHRISTIANITY 89
it meant that things were drawing nearer in Italy. It
may be best, and best that it should be soon, but it makes
one shudder to think of all that it must bring. And he
feels that this must be a crowning struggle ; and if it
fails could he live after it ? After dinner he began
quarrelling with me about Christianity, which he maintains
rank Puseyism as we tell him to be what, and no
more than what, was believed in the first three, or may be
the first five centuries. All that is new since then (even
Purgatory, in which he believes) he calls " philosophizing
upon Christianity," and won't allow Unitarians the name
of Christians. He says it is absurd to give the name of
a religion to all that can possibly be drawn out of it, or
reconciled with it ; that except so far as we believe the
distinctive original doctrines, we might as well call our-
selves also Platonists and Buddhists and Mosaists, for we
have undoubtedly received a great deal of what we are and
believe from all those sources, and more too. Out of this
of course many questions grew ; for instance, what is and
makes Christianity, and what is the right method of
answering the question. Of course I think one quite right
way is : Take Christendom these eighteen hundred years
what is new in it ? and of what is new, what can not be
traced to other sources than Christianity ? If one only
could do it ! But Mr. Martineau can. It all came out of
Mazz.'s asking about the " Christian Socialists " some of
whom have just taken up two new periodicals by Louis
Blanc and saying it was a mistake to call the social
principle Christian ; it belonged to all religions in their
outset ; all taught that men should live for others ; the
distinctively Christian principle was the individual relation
of each man with God ; his independence of human media-
tors ; that every man had to, and could, work out his own
salvation on the conditions prescribed. The social side of
Christianity belonged to it as a religion, not as Christianity ;
that side it had in common with all other religions ; the
essence of re-ligion being somethiug beyond man, which
bound men together, &c. &c. When he was gone, Will