word which has come down to us from the Fathers;—which we found, derived from un-
tutored custom, abiding in unperverted churches;—a word for which the arguments are
strong, and which contributes in no small degree to the completeness of the force of the
mystery?
68. The force of both expressions has now been explained. I will proceed to state once
more wherein they agree and wherein they differ from one another;—not that they are op-
posed in mutual antagonism, but that each contributes its own meaning to true religion.
The preposition “in” states the truth rather relatively to ourselves; while “with” proclaims
the fellowship of the Spirit with God. Wherefore we use both words, by the one expressing
the dignity of the Spirit; by the other announcing the grace that is with us. Thus we ascribe
glory to God both “in” the Spirit, and “with” the Spirit; and herein it is not our word that
we use, but we follow the teaching of the Lord as we might a fixed rule, and transfer His
word to things connected and closely related, and of which the conjunction in the mysteries
is necessary. We have deemed ourselves under a necessary obligation to combine in our
confession of the faith Him who is numbered with Them at Baptism, and we have treated
the confession of the faith as the origin and parent of the doxology. What, then, is to be
done? They must now instruct us either not to baptize as we have received, or not to believe
as we were baptized, or not to ascribe glory as we have believed. Let any man prove if he
can that the relation of sequence in these acts is not necessary and unbroken; or let any man
deny if he can that innovation here must mean ruin everywhere. Yet they never stop dinning
in our ears that the ascription of glory “with” the Holy Spirit is unauthorized and unscrip-
tural and the like. We have stated that so far as the sense goes it is the same to say “glory
be to the Father and to the Son and to the Holy Ghost,” and “glory be to the Father and to
the Son with the Holy Ghost.” It is impossible for any one to reject or cancel the syllable
“and,” which is derived from the very words of our Lord, and there is nothing to hinder the
acceptance of its equivalent. What amount of difference and similarity there is between the
two we have already shewn. And our argument is confirmed by the fact that the Apostle
uses either word indifferently,—saying at one time “in the name of the Lord Jesus and by
the Spirit of our God;”1284 at another “when ye are gathered together, and my Spirit, with
the power of our Lord Jesus,”1285 with no idea that it makes any difference to the connexion
of the names whether he use the conjunction or the preposition.
1284 1 Cor. vi. 11.
1285 1 Cor. v. 4.
235
Of the origin of the word “with,” and what force it has. Also concerning…