28. The argument of the next section is, “In the
day of judgment, no mercy will be shown to the unjust and to sinners,
but they must be consumed in eternal fire.” Who can bear this,
and suffer you to prohibit the mercy of God, and to sit in judgment on
the sentence of the Judge before the day of judgment, so that, if He
wished to show mercy to the unjust and the sinners, He must not,
because you have given your veto? For you say it is written in the one
hundred and fourth Psalm, Ps. civ. 35. “Let
sinners cease to be in the earth, and the wicked be no more.” And
in Isaiah, Is. i. 28. “The wicked and sinners
shall be burned up together, and they who forsake God shall be
consumed.” Do you not know that mercy is sometimes blended with
the threatenings of God? He does not say that they must be burnt with
eternal fires, but let them cease to be in the earth, and the wicked be
no more. For it is one thing for them to desist from sin and
wickedness, another for them to perish for ever and be burnt in eternal
fire. And as for the passage which you quote from Isaiah,
“Sinners and the wicked shall be burned up together,” he
does not add for ever. “And they who forsake God shall be
consumed.” This properly refers to heretics, who leave the
straight path of the faith, and shall be consumed if they will not
return to the Lord whom they have
forsaken. And the same sentence is ready for you if you neglect to turn
to better things. Again, is it not marvellous temerity to couple the
wicked and sinners with the impious, for the distinction between them
is great? Every impious person is wicked and a sinner; but we cannot
conversely say every sinner and wicked person is also impious, for
impiety properly belongs to those who have not the knowledge of God,
or, if they have once had it, lose it by transgression. But the wounds
of sin and wickedness, like faults in general, admit of healing. Hence,
it is written, Ps. xxxii. 10.
“Many are the scourges of the sinner”; it is not said that
he is eternally destroyed. And through all the scourging and torture
the faults of Israel are corrected, Heb. xii. 6.“For whom the Lord loveth He
chasteneth, and scourgeth every son whom He receiveth.” It is one
thing to smite with the affection of a teacher and a parent; another to
be madly cruel towards adversaries. Wherefore, we sing in the first
Psalm, Verse
5. Sept. “The impious do not rise
in the judgment,” for they are already sentenced to destruction;
“nor sinners in the counsel of the just.” To lose the glory
of the resurrection is a different thing from perishing for ever.
“The hour cometh,” he says, S. John v. 28, 29. “In which all that are in the
tombs shall hear His voice, and shall come forth: they that have done
good unto the resurrection of life, and they that have done ill unto
the resurrection of judgment.” And so the Apostle, in the same
sense, because in the same Spirit, says to the Romans, Rom. ii. 12.“As many as have sinned without
law shall also perish without law; and as many as have sinned under
law, shall be judged by law.” The man without law is the
unbeliever who will perish for ever. Under the law is the sinner who
believes in God, and who will be judged by the law, and will not
perish. If the wicked and sinners are to be burned with everlasting
fire, are you not afraid of the sentence you pass on yourself, seeing
that you admit you are wicked and a sinner, while still you argue that
a man is not without sin, but that he may be. It follows that the only
person who can be saved is an individual who never existed, does not
exist, and perhaps never will, and that all our predecessors of whom we
read must perish. Take your own case. You are puffed up with all the
pride of Cato, and have The reference
is to the stature of Pelagius.Milo’s giant shoulders; but is
it not amazing temerity for you, who are a sinner, to take the name of
a teacher? If you are righteous, and, with a false humility, say you
are a sinner, we may be surprised, but we shall rejoice at having so
unique a treasure, and at reckoning amongst our friends a personage
unknown to patriarch, prophet, and Apostle. And if Origen does maintain
that no rational creatures ought to be lost, and allows repentance to
the devil, what is that to us, who say that the devil and his
attendants, and all impious persons and transgressors, perish
eternally, and that The sense of
this passage is much disputed. St. Jerome was, possibly, speaking of
persons who upon the whole are sincere and not merely covenanted
Christians.Christians,
if they be overtaken by sin, must be saved after they have been
punished?